While I was in Park City this summer at PCMI (Park City Mathematics Institute) we were about to leave for dinner when one of the teachers asked Gail Burrill (one of the organizers of the Secondary School Teachers Program) an interesting question. Next thing we know this teacher (I’m not using a name because I promised to keep the photo anonymous!) was taking notes on his hand:
At the time it seemed fun because I thought about how his students might react to taking notes this way. He said he often “freaks them out” by writing on desks. It made me think about how he values taking notes and writing — so much so that he’ll break some “rules” to make sure he writes.
That started me thinking about the note-taking idea itself. He’s going to wash his hand, right? What happens to the notes then? Does he “copy” them to a piece of paper or his computer or somewhere else a bit more permanent? Does he need to do that or does that act of taking notes as Gail was talking help him process the points of that conversation and he can wash his hand without worrying about saving the notes?
Maybe before washing his hand (or the desk) he re-reads the notes, reflects, and writes a new set of notes somewhere?
What would you do? … or … what “do” you do with your notes?



Glad you got to PCMI. The photos of you: http://mathforum.org/pcmi/hstp/sum2011/photos/week3_morning.html -and- http://mathforum.org/pcmi/hstp/sum2011/photos/snow.html are great.
I gave up grading students on THEIR note taking abilities/skills. How each person takes notes is very PERSONAL. How do I grade that? It is extremely tedious and does not help me assess your knowledge and critical thinking skills. I have open notebook and open homework for all tests/quizzes.
Cal tweeted about this and so now I can use his name! He also responded to me by writing:
And that night I did what you described… I sat down, read and reflected on my hand and wrote out full notes and more explanation and shared them with my Functions group (thank you Evernote!).
And when I’m with my kids, I guess I never thought about it as valuing writing so much as valuing mathematics, and since mathematics isn’t shared well “in the air” it needs to be written down in some way. And that’s why my janitor hates me. :)
————–
PCMI 2011 Functions Group: http://mathforum.org/pcmi/hstp/sum2011/wg/functions/
Follow Cal on Twitter: http://twitter.com/sig225