A Math Forum Project

Problem of the Week Logo  
ESCOT Problem of the Week:
Archive of Problems, Submissions, & Commentary

Student Version

Scale 'n Bowl III - posted November 15, 1999

(Try Scale 'n Bowl I and Scale 'n Bowl II before you begin this problem.)

(You'll need to update your Escot Runner for this problem.)

Find a scaling ratio in the form of a fraction (e.g. 2/3) that will enlarge or reduce the blue ball to fit through the green bowling alley and move the two red pins.

  1. For each of the 5 alleys, please explain the scaling ratios you tried, why you tried them, and which one worked.

  2. After you have bowled all 5 alleys, put the scaling ratios that worked in order from smallest to largest, and tell us how you chose this order.

Use this page for further information:



If you are not using the Escot Runner, you must use it to work on this problem.
Other browsers will not display Escot activities
Download the Escot Runner

If you are using the Escot Runner, you may use the link below to download and try this problem.
Want to try it?
Click here to download this problem


Comments

This was the most difficult part of the puzzle for students. Many of them were not able to finish the problem, and therefore did not submit a solution. By this time, students had gotten used to the simulation and question, so most of the difficulty seemed to lie in trying to manipulate fractions to make appropriate scaling ratios.

Through classroom observation, it was noted that students who were successful in finding the correct fraction developed interesting strategies. One common strategy was to increase/decrease the denominator incrementally, and then move on to the numerator. This worked very well. Students used this method spontaneously, and it seemed to improve their understanding of fractions.

However, students had to make lots of guesses to try to figure out the correct solution, and therefore did not write most of their thinking down. Those who did write their solutions tended to give very long answers.

Students also had a great deal of trouble in trying to put the fractions in order, which contradicts the proposition above that students developed a sense of fractional number lines. However, we did see a few students apply the strategy above to answer this question.


4 students received credit this week.

Jack C., age 13 - School of the Arts, San Francisco, CA
Carson D., age 13 - School of the Arts, San Francisco, CA
Wil D., age 13 - School of the Arts, San Francisco, CA
Jeanette G., age 13 - School of the Arts, San Francisco, CA

View most of the solutions submitted by the students above


© 1994-2008 The Math Forum
Contact Us