The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017

Replies: 40   Last Post: Jan 4, 2018 7:37 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Karl-Olav Nyberg

Posts: 1,575
Registered: 12/6/04
Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017

Posted: Dec 28, 2017 3:09 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

torsdag 28. desember 2017 08.28.04 UTC+1 skrev WM følgende:
> Am Donnerstag, 28. Dezember 2017 01:57:44 UTC+1 schrieb konyberg:
> > tirsdag 26. desember 2017 16.14.04 UTC+1 skrev John Gabriel følgende:
> > > Any rational number can be represented in the form p/q with both p and q integers and of course q not 0. All, but one! That is, 0.999... cannot be represented as p/q, unless it is assumed from the beginning that 0.999... and 1 are the same.
> > >
> > > Naturally, 0.999... is an ill-formed concept, just as is 0.333... or anything with an ellipsis following it. These ideas were the sick brainchild of idiot Dutchmen almost 400 years ago. Spurred on by Newton's Blond moments (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rSEN3PsiBcI) and oblivious to the fact that multiplication does not distribute over infinite series (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAdtI4MIotg), the idiot Dutchman Stevin published his crap on decimals. Not all bad, but the idea was to enable one to do arithmetic without any knowledge of fractions. A lofty goal until the 20th century where students don't even care to learn methods such as long division, etc. The calculator now does all this and they've gotten significantly dumber.
> > >
> > > Anyhow, the moron academics of the BIG STUPID cannot find a p/q, such that p/q = 0.999...
> > >
> > > Of course 0.999... is not a number of any kind, but the primates of the BIG STUPID haven't realised this.
> > >
> > > An interesting approach is the fraction n/(n+1) from which it is impossible to arrive at 0.999... no matter how large an n is chosen.
> > >
> > > Ill-formed concepts (especially those derived from the infinity delusion) simply give rise to more ill-formed concepts.
> > >
> > > For a quick debunking of all the so-called proofs:
> > >
> > > https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B-mOEooW03iLS2pmTHMwel9fOTQ
> > >
> > > For a mammoth discussion (50 pages) with musings, magic, etc:
> > >
> > > https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B-mOEooW03iLd3gyMGlWNk02amM

> >
> > This is not a proof as such, but it's a reasonable construction.
> > 1 = 9/9 = 1/9 + 8/9 = 0.111... + 0.888... = 0.999...
> > Show me what's wrong with this.

>
> This is wrong: 1/9 + 8/9 = 0.111... + 0.888...
>
> Correct would be 1/9 + 8/9 = lim{n-->oo} 0.111...1_n + lim{n-->oo} 0.888...8_n
>
> Regards, WM


Does it change the result?
KON



Date Subject Author
12/27/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Karl-Olav Nyberg
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Jan Burse
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Python
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Karl-Olav Nyberg
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Python
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
7777777
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
7777777
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bassam king karzeddin
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
LudovicoVan
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
FromTheRafters
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/3/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bassam king karzeddin
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Dan Christensen

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2018. All Rights Reserved.