The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017

Replies: 40   Last Post: Jan 4, 2018 7:37 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
FromTheRafters

Posts: 248
Registered: 12/20/15
Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Posted: Dec 31, 2017 9:23 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

WM wrote on 12/31/2017 :
> Am Sonntag, 31. Dezember 2017 11:00:37 UTC+1 schrieb Zelos Malum:
>>> Yes. Nobody has denied that. But since oo is no natural number you have not
>>> a sum over terms with natural indices but the limit.

>>
>> Again, oo is a shorthand for the limit and the infinite sum is defiend as
>> the limit.

>
> I agree. But the infinite sum, whether or not defined as the limit, *is* not
> a limit.


True, it is not a limit. It is the limit of the sequence of partial
sums not the infinite sum. The place you are headed, not the
(partial)progress you have made toward it.

> A sum is the addition of summands --- and that is rational for every
> summand added. The adding does never stop, and the rational character of the
> result does never stop.


It is the rational character of the *partial* sums that doesn't stop.

[...]


Date Subject Author
12/27/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Karl-Olav Nyberg
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Jan Burse
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Python
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Karl-Olav Nyberg
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Python
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bursejan@gmail.com
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/28/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/29/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
7777777
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
7777777
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bassam king karzeddin
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/30/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
LudovicoVan
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
FromTheRafters
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/2/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/3/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
zelos.malum@gmail.com
1/4/18
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
wolfgang.mueckenheim@hs-augsburg.de
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
bassam king karzeddin
12/31/17
Read Re: If you claim 0.999... is a rational number, then you must find
p/q such that 0.999... = p/q. 12/26/2017
Dan Christensen

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2018. All Rights Reserved.