Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Learning and Mathematics: Schoenfeld, Metacognition
Replies: 16   Last Post: May 3, 1996 7:46 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Sasha Clayton Posts: 5 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Learning and Mathematics: Schoenfeld, Metacognition
Posted: Mar 25, 1996 2:01 AM

(sseasto1@swarthmore.edu) wrote:
>
>o "One of the problems on the National Assessment of Education Progress
>secondary mathematics exam, administered to a stratified sample of 45,000
>students nationwide, was the following: An army bus holds 36 soldiers. If
>1128 soldiers are being bused to their training site, how many buses are
>needed? Seventy percent of the students who took the exam set up the
>correct long division and performed it correctly. However, the following
>are the answers those students gave to the question how many buses are
>needed: 29% (1 in 3) said the number of buses is '31 remainder 12'; 18%
>said the number of buses needed is "31"; 23% said the number of buses
>needed is '32,' which is correct; (30% did not do the computation
>correctly)... One out of three students said '31 remainder 12'- without
>checking to see if the result made sense! In essence, they treated the
>problem as calling for a formal computation. Despite the 'cover story'
>about the buses, the computation had little or nothing to do with the real
>world" (p. 196).
>

So often, the focus of doing math, is the "doing" part, the getting it done.
In order to get a problem done, a student (and most of us have been this
student) will plug in the formula given by the teacher, or will execute the
long division, without understanding what the formula means, or why it
should be used. I have seen this repeatedly in tutoring. My tutee will
quickly do the problem, just as the teacher has shown him. Yet, when asked
a simple "why" question, he has no idea how to answer, for the "why" has
never been discussed. To him, math is arbitrary steps that he has to do to
numbers to get a correct mark on his paper. The use of metacognition in a
class seems to move the focus to a real understanding of mathematics,
instead of just where to apply formulas.

Students need to be aware of what they are doing and why they are doing it.
Mathematics can easily disolve into a jumble of abstract numbers and signs.
It's so important to give meaning to mathematics. It's not good enough to
just get it done.

--Sasha Clayton

Date Subject Author
3/20/96 Sarah Seastone
3/25/96 Gypsyamber Berg-Cross
3/25/96 Johanna K. Peters-Burton
3/25/96 Sasha Clayton
3/26/96 Nette Witgert
3/26/96 Erika Wenger
3/26/96 Tracy L. Rusch
3/26/96 Sasha Clayton
3/27/96 Stephen Weimar
3/28/96 Cathy Glasheen
4/7/96 Laurie Gerber
4/7/96 Laurie Gerber
4/9/96 Matt Reed
4/17/96 bliss
4/23/96 Richard Tchen
5/2/96 Laurie Gerber
5/3/96 Pat Ballew