Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Topic: Hyperbolas in Nature
Replies: 29   Last Post: Mar 24, 2010 6:05 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 C. Kenneth Fan Posts: 12 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Hyperbolas in nature
Posted: May 14, 1996 4:07 PM

Hi,

I guess precisely, I am refering to the curve which must be drawn upon
a canvas to give the observer with one eye closed, the proper image of
a Hoola-Hoop (tm? gosh...I didn't realize that...) wrapped about the observer.
The ellipse, hyperbola, and parabola are all possible.

John Conway pointed out that without the canvas, the curve is not a conic
section. However, on this, I'm not sure exactly what is really going on.
I agree that the image on the eyeball is not a conic section, but it's not
clear to me that the actual perception is a conic section, because the brain
may be structured to compensate for this. Can someone enlighten me?

I recall hearing about an experiment done with monkeys where monkeys were injected
with radioactive glucose, had there eyes fixed upon a bullseye target, and then
killed. When their brains were dissected, the radioactive glucose literally
made a pattern on the folds of the brain: one, a bullseye pattern, the other,
a grid indicating a polar coordinate transformation.

(I am not requesting that someone do a similar experiment to enlighten me!
However, for me, things are complicated even more because of glasses,...or
are glasses designed not to change matters?)

In any case, finding examples of absolutely true hyperbolas in nature is
probably impossible. (For instance, Jupiter messes up orbits.)

Ken Fan

Date Subject Author
5/3/96 Erica Morse
5/3/96 CALCCOCH@aol.com
5/3/96 Michael Thwaites
8/26/05 K.E.Raghav
8/26/05 K.E.Raghav
5/3/96 John Conway
5/3/96 John Conway
5/4/96 David Masunaga
5/5/96 Brian Hutchings
5/6/96 Lou Talman
5/6/96 John Conway
5/6/96 John Conway
5/7/96 Pat Ballew
5/9/96 Brian Hutchings
5/10/96 C. Kenneth Fan
5/12/96 John Conway
5/13/96 C. Kenneth Fan
5/13/96 Brian Hutchings
5/14/96 C. Kenneth Fan
5/15/96 C. Kenneth Fan
5/15/96 John Conway
5/16/96 Brian Hutchings
3/11/99 runa
5/9/00 Stephanie Ernst
5/11/00 mary krimmel
5/15/00 Niyeda
3/14/03 Erin
3/16/03 Terri Lynn
2/2/10 Jordyn Kabir
3/24/10 viewtech