Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Proofs - My Thoughts
Replies: 11   Last Post: Feb 26, 1993 3:04 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 James King Posts: 66 From: University of Washington Registered: 12/3/04
Re: Two-column Proofs
Posted: Feb 26, 1993 3:04 PM

In article <1mjcv5\$n1a@forum.swarthmore.edu> Michael Rogers,
mkrogers@unix.amherst.edu writes:
>The two-column "method" focuses one's attention on the second
>phase of proving a theorem. It forces one to clearly show why
>your assertions are true. One should also be forced to do this
>in the paragraph style. One problem with the two-column style
>is that it focuses so much attention on the second part of
>proving, the write-up, that students do not realize that they
>are supposed to still do the first part. And as you said,
>without the first part, you are likely to fail to find a proof.

Another problem with two-column proofs is that they offer no
indication of what are the main ideas, the important steps, in the proof.
While from the point of view of formal logic, all steps in a proof are
equally important, from the point of view of mathematical understanding,
usually a proof has one or two key ideas. This is where the AHA!
resides, if there is one.

For this reason, I think it is a very useful exercise to ask a student to
summarize a proof in one sentence. It is also useful to take a
two-column proof, examine it and then mark one or two lines which contain
the main ideas.

Paragraph proofs have the advantage that they are actually written as
communication as well as formal argument, but there is a danger that
someone new two proofs will not realize the formal structure that is
supposed to underly the reasoning in the proof.

Jim King
Dept of Math
University of Washington
Seattle, WA 98195

king@math.washington.edu

Date Subject Author
12/15/92 Bernie Ivens
2/17/93 Bernie Ivens
2/17/93 Michael Rogers
2/17/93 David Fowler
2/17/93 joe malkevitch
2/18/93 Michelle Manes
2/18/93 Rouben Rostamian
2/18/93 Annie Fetter
2/19/93 Michael Rogers
2/19/93 Michael Rogers
2/25/93 Michael Rogers
2/26/93 James King