Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: -1 as a prime
Replies: 15   Last Post: Sep 29, 2000 11:55 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 james dolan Posts: 93 Registered: 12/8/04
-1 as a prime
Posted: Aug 25, 2000 1:47 PM

beable van polasm wrote:

>-1, factors: -1, 1. HEY! NEGATIVE
>ONE IS PRIME! I HEREBY PATENT MY DISCOVERY OF THE WORLD'S
>FIRST NEGATIVE PRIME NUMBER!11!!

sorry, you'll have to get in line behind all of the other cranks and
kooks before you who've made the same "discovery". just last week i
was reading a book where the author presents the idea that -1 is a
prime as his own brilliant idea. he gives a list of four example
statements that he claims are stated most concisely if -1 is
considered to be a prime. his first example is "every nonzero
rational number is uniquely a product of powers of prime numbers p";
apparently he's too stupid to realize that -6 is both 2*3*(-1) and
2*3*(-1)*(-1)*(-1). his second example is "for distinct odd primes
f(p,q) and f(q,p) differ just when p = q = -1 (mod 4)", where f is the
"legendre symbol" function. this is just too brilliant for words:
he's trying to argue that -1 should be treated on the same footing as
the official genuine primes, and he does so by exhibiting a statement
that explicitly makes -1 an exceptional case. needless to say after
those first two examples i didn't bother trying to understand his last
two examples which were full of tell-tale pseudo-jargon like

if you want to make a name for yourself as a prominent mathematical
crank then you'll at least have to try to outdo the guy that wrote
that book.

Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/

Date Subject Author
8/25/00 james dolan
8/25/00 Mikal 606
9/2/00 John Conway
9/3/00 james dolan
9/4/00 Nimish Shah
9/4/00 Virgil Hancher
9/5/00 John Conway
9/4/00 Nimish Shah
9/5/00 John Conway
9/7/00 james dolan
9/8/00 james dolan
9/9/00 John Conway
8/29/00 michael holmes
9/24/00 Li Dek
9/29/00 Li Dek