Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Re: meaningful standards (fwd)
Posted:
May 30, 1995 12:28 PM


Steve: The question that I have with the Basics idea is... When does tomorrow come? When do the specifics finally appear? In other words, students learn whole numbers so they can do fractions, fractions so they can do algebra, algebra so they can do precalculus, precalculus so they can do calculus, ad infinitum. I have heard calculus teachers say, don't worry about understanding, they'll get that in real analysis. Just wondering... Gary Martin, Univ. of Hawaii
On Tue, 30 May 1995, Steve Means wrote:
> In discussing this with my students just now, they introduced a slight > shift in terminology. They think that education is progressive, from > Basic to Specific. The Basics, which are learned earlier in school, > tend to have more general application to support the specific learning > and tasks encountered as the educational demands become focused on > specific career objectives. > > The human mind depends on making generalizations, on making information > more compact. > > It is NOT significant learning to be given a formula (a generalization) > and then be prompted to find the missing values and compute an answer > (unless the lesson is on substitution and/or computation). > > Period Two Algebra with Trig Students 1995 >



