Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Rules and Formulas - Supplied or Not?
Replies: 2   Last Post: May 29, 1995 11:54 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Amos Newcombe Posts: 6 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Rules and Formulas - Supplied or Not?
Posted: May 29, 1995 1:32 PM

Rex Boggs writes,

>Should we supply on the exam paper such things as
>sin^2 + cos^2 = 1, (ab)^n = a^n b^n, log(ab) = log a + log b, the chain
>rule for differential calculus, etc,, and concentrate on whether students
>can apply the correct rule correctly. Or are these part of the body of
>mathematical knowledge that a good student should have at their fingertips?
>
>In Queensland, we have external exams for mature age learners. The Maths in
>Society exam has the formulas supplied, the Maths B and Maths C exams
>(roughly equivalent to Algebra II, and Calculus and Analytical Geometry)
>don't. So even within our system there appears to be differing attitudes.

I am not a teacher at this level, but I have had a number of semi-technical
jobs and hobbies where algebraic manipulation was necessary. If I did not
know the formulas you give, I would be in sad shape. Or rather, I would,
through practice, quickly learn them. I would hope that the course they
took gave them enough practice so you wouldn't have to give them formulas
like this. If they don't know that (ab)^n = a^n b^n or log(ab) = log a +
log b, then how can you say they really know exponents or logarithms?

In the case of sin^2 + cos^2 = 1, this one is pretty basic to doing any
kind of trig calculations, but for trig identities in general, there are so
many of them and they are so interrelated that no one can expect to know
them all. Maybe give them the standard identities, but problems that depend
not on those, but identities that can be derived from them.

In the case of the chain rule, and in general, the answer depends on what
you want them to know when the course is over. If the Maths in Society
course -- like many similarly-named courses in the USA -- is intended for
people who are going no further with math, giving them the formulas may be
appropriate. If you are training scientists and engineers, they obviously
need to know the chain rule after their first calculus course; they will
need it soon and often.

Amos Newcombe | Voice (914) 339-0582 | The world's biggest fool
CyberMath | Fax (914) 331-2697 | can say the sun is shining,
Manor Lake #2 | Email: amos@cerf.net, | but that doesn't make it
Kingston NY 12401 | 76324.3313@compuserve.com | dark out. -- Robert Pirsig

Date Subject Author
5/29/95 Rex Boggs
5/29/95 Amos Newcombe
5/29/95 Ed Wall