Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Re: Borda count
Posted:
Nov 16, 2000 5:14 PM


Guy Brandenburg wrote:
> > My souces for this lesson were, more or less, the COMAP book For All > Practical purposes, which is an interesting source of ideas; columns I > had read a long time ago in Scientific American by Martin Gardner and I > suspect others on Kenneth Arrow's apparent proof that the only type of > election procedure that actually follows a few apparently simple axioms > is a dictatorship; and a much more recent article on voting theory by a > person whose name I cannot recall right now because I forgot to bookmark > it and instead simply printed out and took to school. He contradicts > Arrow. I will attempt to find this citation on Monday.
I went through Arrow's work not long ago. The original paper is quite hard to read, because Arrow uses terminology that is very unfamiliar to people whose mathematical background is more modern. A very readable modern work on the subject is Alan D. Taylor's book *Mathematics and Politics: Strategy, Voting, Power and Proof*, SpringerVerlag, New York, 1995, ISBN 0387943919.
I doubt that the other author you mentioned contradicts Arrow, whose work seems correct to me. However, Arrow's Theorem depends on some carefully stated definitions, and it may be the case that the other author used somewhat different definitions which don't support Arrow's reasoning or his conclusions.
Lou Talman Department of Mathematical and Computer Sciences Campus Box 38 Metropolitan State College of Denver PO Box 173362 Denver CO 802173362
http://clem.mscd.edu/~talmanl



