Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Integer matrix rank
Replies: 4   Last Post: Oct 22, 1999 7:18 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Thom Mulders Posts: 8 Registered: 12/8/04
Re: Integer matrix rank
Posted: Oct 20, 1999 5:05 AM

Dear Jim,

You can use a modular method. When A is your matrix, compute for N different
primes p the rank of (A modulo p). When the product of the primes you use
is sufficiently big, then the rank will be equal to the maximum of the ranks
you have computed.
To be specific. Let A be an n by m matrix (n<=m) and ||A|| a bound on the
entries in A. When r is the rank of A there is an r by r submatrix B of A
with det(B)<>0. When the product Q of the primes exceeds det(B), there must
be at least one prime p such that the rank of (B modulo p) is r and thus the
rank of (A modulo p) is r. Using Hadamard's bound we have
det(B) <= r^{r/2}||A||^r <= n^{n/2}||A||^n,
so you need at most n((log n)/2 + log ||A||) different primes.
Since the complexity of computing the rank of (A modulo p) is O(mn^2) (assuming
the prime is not too big, e.g. fits into a machine word), the complexity of
this algorithm is (up to some log factors) O(mn^3). This is better than the
complexity (O(mn^4)) of the fraction free algorithm proposed before.

You can also use a probabilistic version of the above. Take a set S of at least
2n((log n)/2 + log ||A||) different primes and compute the rank of (A modulo p)
for different random primes from S. For such a random prime, the probability
that the rank of (A modulo p) is the rank of A is at least 1/2. When you find
that the rank does not increase for N choices of p, then the probability
that you have found the right rank is at least 1-(1/2)^N. Taking N=20, the
probability of failure is less than one in a million. Increasing the set S
improves the probability of success.

I hope this helps.

Regards,

Thom Mulders

Thom Mulders
Institute of Scientific Computing
ETH Zurich

In article <s8x904zn11i.fsf@gold.cics.shef.ac.uk>, john green <ap1jjg@gold.cics.shef.ac.uk> writes:
|> Hello all.
|>
|> I was wondering if anyone knew of a method
|> specific to the problem of finding the rank
|> of a large dense matrix with (small) integer
|> entries.
|>
|> Thanks.
|>
|> Jim Green
|> --
|> J.J.Green, Dept. Applied Math. University of Sheffield, UK
|> http://www.arbs.demon.co.uk

Date Subject Author
10/19/99 john green
10/19/99 Peter Spellucci
10/20/99 Thom Mulders
10/21/99 john green
10/22/99 Thom Mulders