Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Topic: -1 x -1 ?
Replies: 29   Last Post: May 13, 2009 9:01 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 John Savard Posts: 601 Registered: 12/8/04
Re: -1 x -1 ?
Posted: Sep 18, 1999 1:38 PM

"Guillermo Phillips" <Guillermo.Phillips@marsman.demon.co.uk> wrote,
in part:

>Here's something I've always wondered (perhaps in my naivety). Why
>should -1 x -1 = 1?
>I appreciate that lots of nice things come from this, but what's the
>fundamental reason for it?

Well, negative numbers are kind of strange, almost like imaginary
numbers. You have an empty box, and you can leave it empty, or you can
put one pebble in it, or you can put two pebbles in it, and so on.

But negative numbers can make sense for things like temperature and
bank accounts.

If you owe five dollars, that can be considered a way of having -5
dollars.

If you owe three people five dollars, you have 3 * -5 dollars, or -15
dollars.

If three people owe you five dollars, then you have an asset that is
(hopefully, if they're honest) worth 15 dollars. So that's -3 * -5,
the minus on the 3 standing for the fact that the debt is "the other
way around".

John Savard ( teneerf<- )
http://www.ecn.ab.ca/~jsavard/crypto.htm

Date Subject Author
9/16/99 Guillermo Phillips
9/16/99 Ian A. Mason
9/16/99 Peter Percival
9/16/99 Dave Seaman
9/17/99 Steve Leibel
9/17/99 Dale Henderson
9/18/99 Peter Percival
9/18/99 Bill Taylor
9/18/99 John Savard
9/19/99 carel
9/20/99 Jon Haugsand
9/20/99 HH
9/20/99 Jon Haugsand
9/20/99 Jonathan Hoyle
9/20/99 Jim Hunter
1/21/09 Tay
1/21/09 mensanator
1/21/09 lwalke3@lausd.net
1/22/09 Henry
1/22/09 David R Tribble
1/22/09 Dave L. Renfro
1/22/09 mensanator
5/12/09 Kayama
5/12/09 mensanator
5/12/09 hagman
5/12/09 Bill Dubuque
5/12/09 Bill Taylor
5/13/09 Cobra
5/13/09 Cobra