>Ahhh...gotcha. That is indeed an interesting question. I'm not sure >what the answer is. I know that many new functions are co-opted from >similar functions (I think the classical example is some enzyme >beginning with the letter l...but can't remember right now). But that >begs the question of where the co-opted behaviors came from.
True, and I think also the important issue is how this new function arose from a similar function. The evolution, and natural selection, of classes of beta-lactamases are the examples I know. While we haven't observed it, the early beta-lactamases are hypothesised to have arisen from cell-wall enzymes and the bacteria were facing an enemy in nature (beta-lactams in fungi). Today, we have artificial beta-lactams that are not seen anywhere in nature, yet there are bacteria resistant to it. One explanation that this new function /arose/ (evolved) in the the last few decades, compared to the initial ones, which might've been around for thousands of years and then were selected for when we first developed beta-lactams? Or maybe the genes were already present for all classes of beta-lactams?
I think natural selection is a very strong theory. Evolution, on the other hand, poses interesting questions (like the ones above).
On further thoughts, I think there are two definitions of evolution (at least). Evolution, as a subject, refers to the entire process: arising of function, and natural selection. That is, how a species evolves over time. Evolution can also simply refer to the arising of new function.
>I have seen the new evidence supporting some Lamarkian mechanism, so >your last question does merit some investigation.
Yes, there're some papers in Nature about adaptive mutation I read a while ago.
Also, relevant to this is the mechanism of antibody formation. That's basically evolution and natural selection in our bodies.
firstname.lastname@example.org || http://www.ram.org || http://www.twisted-helices.com/th Let's not judge outselves by race, religion, colour, or by sex. Let's reach out to one another bring out our very best. We believe in what we're sayin' so put your trust in us. We express ourselves by playin', we're called Psychefunkapus.