Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: analytic function problem
Replies: 76   Last Post: Oct 28, 1996 11:08 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Tleko

Posts: 341
Registered: 12/12/04
Re: analytic function problem
Posted: Oct 7, 1996 8:52 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply




In article <52ro6p$mcm@aplinfo.jhuapl.edu> Hunter James
<hunter@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu> wrote:

: I see what you mean. And with that observation, we have the jingo:
:
: y is an analytic function of both z and z*, if, and only if,
: it is a "function" of neither.

Indeed we have z=z* .

We write z=r.exp(i.@)

z*=r.exp(i.(-@))

to obtain z-z*=r.((cos@+i.sin@)-(cos(-@)+i.sin(-@-pi))) = 0 .

---------------------------------------------

In the article <199610062112.OAA1437@alumni.caltech.edu>
Ilias Kastanas wrote:

: Your statement that z = z* bears no relation to the fact that if
: f(z) is analytic then df/dz* = 0. You are saying that x + iy = x -
iy,
: which is complete and unadulterated nonsense.

What is df/dz* ?

: You do not listen to or think about what other people say.

Some people say but they don't think.
-------------------------------------------------------
In article
<199610070856.KAAO1897@maloche.neuroinformatik.ruhr-uni-bochum.de>
David Kastrup <dak@fsnif.neuroinformatik.ruhr-uni-bohum.de> wrote:
>
> In article <52ro6p$mcm@aplinfo.jhuapl.edu> Hunter James
> <hunter@aplcomm.jhuapl.edu> wrote:
> : I see what you mean. And with that observation, we have the jingo:
> :
> : y is an analytic function of both z and z*, if, and only if,
> : it is a "function" of neither.


Indeed we have z=z* .

We write z=r.exp(i.@)

z*=r.exp(i.(-@))

to obtain z-z*=r.((cos@+i.sin@)-(cos(-@)+i.sin(-@-pi))) = 0 .

> This above all proves that you are not wanting to make any sensible
> claims but are just out to "prove" nonsense by mixing your geometric
> functions up. The "-pi" in the above is absolute nonsense and not
> justifiable at all. If you cross out that junk, you arrive at
> z-z* = 2 r i sin@
>
> Which is, pretty obvious for all bu the hopefully dense, the 2i Im(z)
> which you could have arrived at without employing polar coordinates.
>
> As you don't seem to be interested in any sane arguments, I'd ask you
> not to write to me any more.


Thanks,

--
David Kastrup Institut fuer Neuroinformatik, Ruhr-Universitaet Bochum
Email: dak@neuroinformatik.ruhr-uni-bochum.de Telephon: +49-234-700-5570
-----------------------------------------------







Date Subject Author
9/30/96
Read analytic function problem
Christopher
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Hunter James D. STA x4202
10/1/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/1/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/1/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Hunter James D. STA x4202
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Zdislav V. Kovarik
9/30/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Anne DeCampo
10/2/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Christopher
10/1/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/2/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/3/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Zdislav V. Kovarik
10/5/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/5/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/6/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/6/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich
10/7/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/7/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/7/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Andreas Leitgeb
10/7/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Andreas Leitgeb
10/7/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/9/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Simon Read
10/8/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/8/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Zdislav V. Kovarik
10/8/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/9/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich
10/8/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Jim Hunter
10/8/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/9/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/9/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Ilias Kastanas
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/12/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/12/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/11/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/12/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/12/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Sue Franklin
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Ilias Kastanas
10/15/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Simon Read
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/14/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/13/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/14/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
ilias kastanas 08-14-90
10/14/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/15/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/15/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/15/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Ilias Kastanas
10/16/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/16/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/17/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Raymond DeCampo
10/18/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Ariel Scolnicov
10/19/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/19/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/20/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Terry Moore
10/21/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Dik T. Winter
10/22/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Ariel Scolnicov
10/20/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/21/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Terry Moore
10/22/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/23/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Tleko
10/24/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
Gunter Bengel
10/28/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Kastrup
10/28/96
Read Re: analytic function problem
David Ullrich

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.