Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Which Polynomial?
Replies: 28   Last Post: Jul 27, 2006 3:13 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Wayne Bishop Posts: 5,465 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Which Polynomial?
Posted: Aug 2, 2005 1:02 PM

At 08:51 AM 8/2/2005, Victor Steinbok wrote:
>At 02:06 AM 8/2/2005, Wayne Bishop wrote:
>>Except for kids of semi-affluent semi-educated parents who are
>>headed for a superior score in AP Calculus. Extrapolate to life success.

>
>That's right, kids! Extrapolate your AP Calculus scores to life
>success. So if you get a 3 or a 2, you must be a failure

There's a small problem here, but a well recognized one in the
standard toolkit of fallacious reasoning and snake-oil sales; a
statement and its inverse need not be logically equivalent. It is
especially obvious in this case where an AP Calculus score of even a
2 *does* indicate a student following the low to middle class canon
of academic and life success. But not a 1 and not AP Calculus on the
high school transcript but no ETS score at all.

Wayne.

Date Subject Author
7/30/05 Kirby Urner
7/30/05 talmanl@mscd.edu
7/30/05 Victor Steinbok
7/30/05 Kirby Urner
7/31/05 Victor Steinbok
7/31/05 Kirby Urner
7/31/05 luciepoirier
7/31/05 Kirby Urner
7/31/05 luciepoirier
7/31/05 Victor Steinbok
8/1/05 Kirby Urner
8/1/05 Kirby Urner
8/1/05 talmanl@mscd.edu
8/2/05 Wayne Bishop
8/2/05 Victor Steinbok
8/2/05 Wayne Bishop
8/2/05 Victor Steinbok
8/4/05 luciepoirier
8/2/05 talmanl@mscd.edu
8/2/05 Kirby Urner
7/30/05 Pam
7/30/05 talmanl@mscd.edu
7/31/05 luciepoirier
7/30/05 Kirby Urner
7/31/05 Victor Steinbok
7/31/05 Kirby Urner
9/20/05 Kirby Urner
3/14/06 Kirby Urner
7/27/06 Kirby Urner