Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Curricula » Investigations Other Topics

Topic: Parents
Replies: 118   Last Post: Oct 31, 2006 5:29 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
SAS

Posts: 4
From: virginia
Registered: 10/20/05
Re: Parents
Posted: Nov 30, 2005 5:29 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Thank you, Joycer, for telling it like it is. My son's school adopted this idiotic curriculum the year he entered Kindergarten. You are absolutely right on about the problems it creates for discipline in the classroom, as there are so many things other than math that the kids want to talk about--or do-- like, run around the classroom and throw unifix cubes! I am not a math teacher, but I have witnessed the chaos of the Investigations math class firsthand as a parent while volunteering, and later as an concerned (and disgusted) viewer.
The "Pockets" exercise could have been a great lesson as an intro to multiplication or adding multiple numbers, had anything been written up for the entire class to see and comprehend. Instead, a couple of kids dominated the class and nothing was shown for the rest of the kids to get a grip on what they were doing, no explanations were given. This was followed by the "Guess my rule" game. What a total waste of time. Then there was the lesson about finding area--of lips with (non-uniform) beans! They hadn't even covered multiplication yet. One would expect the first area lesson to maybe involve a square or rectangle, something simple. I failed to see the point. And base 7?! Please! What about base 10???
I agree with you about the treatment of fractions (my son is in grade 5 now). They gloss over the meat and talk "concepts", then rapidly move on to statistics and a lengthy jumping in class exercise. How do the kids understand a concept, let alone write about it, if they don't ever work through anything with pencil and paper or see an operation worked out correctly? Fraction strips are extremely limited in their uses...I told my son to set everything to a common denominator (what's that?). He refused because it wasn't promoted as a "best strategy" of some other child in the class or perhaps his partner that day. Oh, but he nearly failed the test, because even though it wasn't taught, he was expected to have somehow intuited that "common denominators" was the approach that would give the correct answer consistently. Hmmm...no mention of common denominators.
After about grade 2 our school strictly limits the option to visit classes, and it is implied that we should not come to math class to see for ourselves how class is conducted. My suspicion is that my son must listen to a host of children talk on about some half-baked "strategy" of theirs and that he tunes out mid-class. He would miss any pertinent information, provided it were given. He also likes to let others do the work for him in class, and group learning/work is encouraged and deemed preferable to individual work.
I started supplementing his math education at home once I realised he couldn't do simple addition or subtraction without the use of manipulatives by mid-2nd grade. Remarkably, he was considered above grade level! He knows his multiplication facts because I made him learn them, not because they are required by this curriculum. Likewise, his skills in addition, subtraction, long division and fractions were learned at home, not at school, but I suppose the school district will look great for implementing Investigations because the SOL scores are good due to parents like me who work ceaselessly with our children to keep them up to grade level. Recently, the school has asked parents to work on math facts at home...excuse me, but isn't that the school's job first, and my responsibility to reinforce? What do they do all day in class? My son is angry that I make him do additional work at home, but he now knows that it is what he learns at home that will carry him through the class.
One of my main concerns about TERC is that there is way too much emphasis on writing out "strategies" when simple operation answers should suffice. My son, who isn't brilliant at writing, one time loved math because he could "do" it. He now hates it because he must explain away something that he could write out with numbers. He (as do I) hates the lengthy, convoluted and poorly written word problems that comprise sometimes nearly 30% of a test. Don't get it right, automatic failure.
All concerns I have voiced have been brushed aside. I am fed up enough that I have recently contacted a school board member in hopes of some remedy to this awful situation. Isn't there something that can be done to get this out of the schools? Do you get parents who are upset with this at your school, too? Are there other teachers out there who care about the decline in math ability and comprehension because of Investigations Math? The teachers here make me feel I am singular in my dismay, yet I know a handful of other parents who are also alarmed.
Thanks for voicing the truth.


Date Subject Author
12/14/99
Read Parents
Discussion Facilitator
3/23/00
Read problems with the TERC math
leonie Haimson
3/23/00
Read TERC math
Nancy
3/25/00
Read Re: TERC math
Sam Morris
3/27/00
Read Re: Re: TERC math
leonie Haimson
3/27/00
Read Re: Re: Re: TERC math
Rachelle Tome
4/2/00
Read Re: Re: Re: TERC math
Sam Morris
3/27/00
Read Re: TERC math
leonie Haimson
3/27/00
Read Re: TERC math
Nancy
4/3/00
Read Re: Re: TERC math
Mary Brown
6/3/00
Read Re: Re: TERC math
E.A. Miller
4/9/00
Read Re: TERC math
Missy Taft
11/2/00
Read Help with Terc - from a parents perspective
patty
11/12/00
Read Re: Help with Terc - from a parents perspective
Sam Morris
11/1/04
Read Re: Help with Terc - from a parents perspective
Bianca Shepherd
11/2/04
Read Re: Re: Help with Terc - from a parents perspective
Elizabeth carson
12/10/00
Read TERC
Maureen Weinberg
8/3/06
Read Alfonso E Munoz Lama
Alfonso E Munoz Lama
12/12/00
Read TERC
mikeden
12/12/00
Read Re: TERC
Wendy Gulley
1/6/02
Read Re: Re: TERC
Bill Quirk
1/6/02
Read Re: Re: TERC
Elizabeth carson
12/13/00
Read Re: TERC
Cindy Stogsdill
1/6/02
Read Re: TERC
Janine Canty
1/7/02
Read Re: Re: TERC
Bob Meyer
4/5/01
Read Geometry
Angie
4/5/01
Read Re: Geometry/area and perimeter
Cornelia Tierney
5/29/01
Read TERC
Jonathan Goodman
7/20/01
Read Investigations in Number ,Data ,And Space
Elizabeth carson
1/6/02
Read CESAME discussions and assumptions about TERC
Elizabeth carson
1/6/02
Read We censor links but not ideas and opinions
Wendy Gulley
9/24/02
Read Terc Math ......the new Whole language approach to Math
Lisa
9/24/02
Read Re: Terc Math ......the new Whole language approach to Math
Christine Larson
9/24/02
Read Re: Terc Math ......the new Whole language approach to Math
mikeden
9/29/02
Read Re: Terc Math ......the new Whole language approach to Math
Mark
10/24/02
Read Investigations Math
Lisa Eisenbud
10/25/02
Read Re: Investigations Math
Cynthia Garland-Dore
10/25/02
Read Re: Re: Investigations Math
Rachelle Tome
10/25/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Investigations Math
Elizabeth carson
10/25/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Investigations Math
Cynthia Garland-Dore
9/9/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Investigations Math
Jenny in Washington State
9/10/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Investigations Math
Bob
10/28/02
Read Investigations Curriculum Value
Susan Pfohman
10/29/02
Read Re: Investigations Curriculum Value
Elizabeth carson
11/1/02
Read Terc math and a parental uprising
Russell Scott
11/1/02
Read Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Mary Ellen Krueger
11/1/02
Read Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Russell Scott
11/12/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Betty Hess
11/12/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Russell Scott
11/12/02
Read Terc math curriculum Information
Cynthia Garland-Dore
11/12/02
Read Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Elizabeth carson
11/12/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Elizabeth carson
11/13/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Mary Ellen Krueger
11/13/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Elizabeth carson
11/13/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Mary Ellen Krueger
11/13/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Elizabeth Carson
2/12/05
Read Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
Mark Trentacoste
10/31/06
Read Re: Re: Terc math and a parental uprising
CrypticLife
11/14/02
Read Help -- my child is drowning in math!
Eve Brown
11/15/02
Read Re: Help -- my child is drowning in math!
RIPAEE
11/20/02
Read Re: Re: Help - drowning - what do TERC experts think?
Eve Brown
11/22/02
Read Re: Re: Re: Help - drowning - what do TERC experts think?
Mark
11/20/02
Read Re: Help -- my child is drowning in math!
Dona T. Apple
11/22/02
Read Gifted children
Bob
12/3/02
Read Re: Gifted children
Eve Brown
12/3/02
Read Drowning
Eve Brown
12/12/02
Read Re: Drowning
Marie Ebersole
12/14/02
Read Drowning: A life ring for you!
Lola
12/17/02
Read Re: Drowning: A life ring for you!
Marie Ebersole
12/17/02
Read Interesting article!
Paul Hickman
11/2/05
Read Re: Interesting article!
Niele Mahaoe
2/11/03
Read Help wanted: integrated math programs
Judi
3/20/03
Read Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Mark
3/20/03
Read Re: Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Julie Clark
3/20/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Cynthia Garland-Dore
3/20/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Susan Surby
3/20/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Julie Clark
3/20/03
Read Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Susan Surby
11/2/05
Read Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
Niele Mahaoe
12/3/05
Read Re: Help wanted: integrated math programs
debbie cluff
4/2/03
Read math topics
Tom
4/4/03
Read Investigations
Judi
4/23/03
Read "proven methods?"
Patty Carpenter
4/23/03
Read Re: proven methods?
Cindy Stogsdill
4/23/03
Read Re: Re: proven methods?
Patty Carpenter
4/23/03
Read Re: Re: Re: proven methods?
Julie Clark
11/9/04
Read Here's a handy test to see if Asian curricula and TERC Investigations are comparable.
Sara R
8/29/03
Read Hi, I'm not a parent but I have a question for parents with gifted children.
Lynn
8/29/03
Read Re: Hi, I'm not a parent but I have a question for parents with gifted children.
Cindy Stogsdill
9/11/03
Read Investigations
Bob Nagle
10/22/03
Read Investigations Math
Sherri Copeland
10/26/03
Read Re: Investigations Math
Angela Kiser
5/1/05
Read Re: Investigations Math
Megan E
11/13/03
Read Re: Investigations Math
Lisa Eisenbud
3/12/04
Read What This Means for us in Practical Terms
Eugenia
3/17/04
Read Re: What This Means for us in Practical Terms
Bob Nagle
3/18/04
Read Re: What This Means for us in Practical Terms
Paul Hickman
11/20/04
Read Re: What This Means for us in Practical Terms
Bree Metzger
4/9/05
Read Re: What This Means for us in Practical Terms
Cynthiia
11/22/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
11/30/05
Read Re: Parents
SAS
12/4/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
10/31/06
Read Re: Parents
CrypticLife
11/22/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
12/5/05
Read Re: Parents
SAS
12/7/05
Read Why no algorithms?
bundle
12/9/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
12/9/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
12/9/05
Read Re: Parents
bundle
12/9/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
12/9/05
Read Re: Parents
Joycer
1/5/06
Read Re: Parents
SAS
8/24/06
Read Re: Parents
Correctanswer
10/31/06
Read Re: Parents
CrypticLife
3/5/06
Read Re: Parents
Linda Moran
7/9/06
Read Re: Parents
kris_0424_cricket
10/8/06
Read Re: Parents
thinkingrules
10/11/06
Read Re: Parents
Wendy Covington
10/31/06
Read Re: Parents
CrypticLife

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.