Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Replies: 67   Last Post: Feb 10, 2006 2:21 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
apoorv

Posts: 88
Registered: 6/18/05
Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Posted: Dec 29, 2005 6:36 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

The question whether N belongs to N is really the same as whether the axiom of infinity is consistent with the axiom of foundation.

As per the axiom of infinity,
N={0}U {Sx: x e N}

Now, the axiom of foundation requires that each x satisfy the condition Sx !=x, or equivalently,
the condition x !e x. (In fact, x!ex <->Sx!=x).
Then, N={0}U{Sx: x e N, and x!ex}
Also, Sx:x e N, <->y:y e N, y!=0
And, x:x!ex <->Sx:Sx !e Sx <->y:y !e y.
Then,

N={0}U{y:yeN, y!=0,and y !e y },
Or,N is the set containing 0 and those sets which are in N and do not contain themselves. The condition y e N is tautological and the only constraint is y!e y.
So,

N={0} U {y:y !=0 ,and y !e y}.

In other words, the axiom of infinity implies that N is precisely the set of those ordinals that do not contain themselves. We know that this set is not well defined.

-Apoorv


Date Subject Author
6/18/05
Read Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
6/19/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
6/22/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
6/22/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Martin Semerád
6/28/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
6/28/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Virgil
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
6/28/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Martin Semerád
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Martin Semerád
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
6/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Martin Semerád
6/30/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
6/30/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Dik T. Winter
7/1/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Martin Semerád
7/1/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Dik T. Winter
7/1/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
7/4/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
7/4/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
7/8/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
7/8/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
7/9/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
7/9/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
7/11/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
7/11/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
7/12/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
8/16/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
8/17/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
8/23/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/1/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/2/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/3/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/3/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/4/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/4/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/6/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/6/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/11/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/11/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
David Kastrup
9/11/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/14/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/15/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/21/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/21/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/23/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/23/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/24/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/24/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/26/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/26/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Rainer Rosenthal
10/2/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
10/2/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Virgil
10/3/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/21/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/21/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/24/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
9/24/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Timothy Little
9/26/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
10/12/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
11/7/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
fernando revilla
1/9/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
12/29/05
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
1/2/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
1/2/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
Virgil
1/3/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
2/10/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv
1/9/06
Read Re: Is the set N of natural numbers well defined?
apoorv

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.