Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.



Re: An old SAT problem
Posted:
Apr 10, 2007 11:29 AM


quasi wrote: > On 10 Apr 2007 07:46:34 0700, "Pubkeybreaker" <pubkeybreaker@aol.com> > wrote:
> > Exactly. So in the real world, when you have to make a decision, and > you can't ask a question on the spot to clarify the precise meaning of > the question, it's reasonable to make the most natural choices for the > unstated assumptions.
Most natural for whom?? For some people the most natural assumption *is* that when one computes rates of return, it is the rate of return on an income *stream* and thus assumes that all monies received are re invested. The solution to a problem should NOT depend on the level of domain expertise of the problem solver.
>To some extent, that could be viewed as part of > what is being tested for  the common sense to keep the > interpretation simple.
I disagree. With this interpretation questions are no longer just about solving a mathematical problem, but also about *guessing* what the poser of the question intended. This can be a cultural/psychological matter that has nothing to do with mathematics.
Mathematical questions should be posed in a clear concise manner that does *not* require interprtation of intent.
It would have been easy in the original question to state: "simple annual interest". Failure to do so is a reflection of the lack of competence of the one who wrote the problem.



