Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math.independent

Topic: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Replies: 176   Last Post: Jun 10, 2007 12:30 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Michael Press

Posts: 2,104
Registered: 12/26/06
Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Posted: May 23, 2007 12:22 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

In article
<25532203.1179814799521.JavaMail.jakarta@nitrogen.mathforum.org>,
Jack Sarfatti <sarfatti@pacbell.net> wrote:

> Check any quantum optics book. There are real experimental effects that cannot be explained by not quantizing the EM vector field along with the electron spinor field.
>
> One example is entangled light like in the Aspect experiment.
>
> You cannot explain nonlocal photon pair polarization and also momentum correlations with classical EM stochastic fields.
>
> e.g. one of the Bell states
>
> |12> = (1/2)^1/2(|1+>|2+> + |1->|2->]
>
> with +- a linear polarization basis defined by orientations in space of linear polarizer.


You cannot exhibit a photon. It remains a theory with no referent.

--
Michael Press


Date Subject Author
5/12/07
Read Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
hanson
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Aatu Koskensilta
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
John Sefton
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
John Sefton
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Olea
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
mike3
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Jake
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Grouchy
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Denis Feldmann
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Mitchell Jones
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/17/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Why Michael Press does not know what he is talking about.
Jack Sarfatti
5/22/07
Read Re: theories of light?
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Re: theories of light?
Jack Sarfatti
5/24/07
Read Re: theories of light?
Michael Press
5/24/07
Read Michael Press is a Crank Crackpot
Jack Sarfatti
5/24/07
Read Re: Michael Press is a Crank Crackpot
T.H. Ray
5/24/07
Read Re: Michael Press is a Crank Crackpot
Denis Feldmann
5/24/07
Read Blind and stupid
Jack Sarfatti
5/25/07
Read Re: physics of light.
Michael Press
5/24/07
Read Re: theories of light?
Dr. David Kirkby
5/25/07
Read Re: theories of light?
T.H. Ray
5/25/07
Read Re: theories of light?
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Re: theories of light?
galathaea
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/24/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
ZZBunker
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/24/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/24/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read This post by Michael Press is crank
Jack Sarfatti
5/22/07
Read Re: This post by Michael Press is crank
Dr. David Kirkby
5/23/07
Read Re: This post by Michael Press is crank
Jack Sarfatti
5/23/07
Read Re: What is light?
Michael Press
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
RAYN.NADERI@gmail.com
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
RAYN.NADERI@gmail.com
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
RAYN.NADERI@gmail.com
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
RAYN.NADERI@gmail.com
5/24/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/23/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/19/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Phineas T Puddleduck
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/20/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Vend
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/21/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/22/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Michael Press
5/22/07
Read Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Jack Sarfatti
5/22/07
Read Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/23/07
Read Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Jack Sarfatti
5/23/07
Read Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Michael Press
5/23/07
Read Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
kundan
5/24/07
Read Re: Why what Michael Press says about photons is bunk
Michael Press
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Eric Gisse
5/12/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
T.H. Ray
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Dr. David Kirkby
5/13/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
ZZBunker
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
PD
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/14/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
David Bernier
5/15/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
mike3
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
ZZBunker
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
mike3
5/16/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
5/18/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings
5/24/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
mike3
6/8/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Traveler
6/10/07
Read Re: Why Quantum Computing Is Bunk
Brian Quincy Hutchings

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2013. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.