The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » math-history-list

Topic: RMP # 48
Replies: 70   Last Post: Jul 23, 2010 8:57 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Milo Gardner

Posts: 1,105
Registered: 12/3/04
Re: RMP # 48
Posted: Oct 4, 2007 9:02 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Lee,

Many have tried to parse MMP 10 connected to the RMP much as you have suggested. One example is provided by:

http://www.math.buffalo.edu/mad/Ancient-Africa/mad_ancient_egypt_geometry.html

Note the sacred geometry reference. I have never seen rigorous proof that Egyptians thought of geometry as sacred. Greeks may have thought in that manner, but Egyptians, no. Sylvia Couchard's paper hopefully will not include a sacred element.

To my view, Egyptians wrote their highest form mathematics in Egyptian fractions, thereby trying to write out exact statements. Of course, early on, Egyptians discovered that certain relationships, like pi, could not be exactly calculated, hence approximations (like a rough value for pi) were substituted.

Concerning volume computations concerning a cylinder, used for a silo to hold grain, the hekat was calculated on a poor 256/81 approximation for pi. Yet, the hekat and its sub-units were rigorously handled by scribes as if the beginning unit was exact. Thus, from this view, one that I may modify after looking closely at Sylvia's paper, and other papers that parse scribal geometry, scribes thought more of Egyptian fraction exactness than geometrical exactness.

Thanks for the opportunity to comment.

Best Regards,

Milo Gardner


Date Subject Author
9/30/07
Read RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/1/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/1/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/1/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/1/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/2/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/3/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/3/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/3/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/4/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/5/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/5/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/7/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/7/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/7/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/7/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/8/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/8/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/8/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/8/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/9/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/9/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/10/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/11/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/11/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/15/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Franz Gnaedinger
10/18/07
Read Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Ed Wall
10/19/07
Read Re: Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Franz Gnaedinger
10/20/07
Read Re: Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Milo Gardner
12/5/07
Read Re: Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Milo Gardner
12/14/07
Read Re: Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Franz Gnaedinger
12/14/07
Read Re: Discussion of error/mistake in Greek texts
Milo Gardner
12/14/07
Read Schools of Egyptology, and why they are not leaders in scribal math studies
Milo Gardner
10/11/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
L. Cooper
7/11/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Dioxippus
7/12/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
7/20/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Dioxippus
7/21/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
7/21/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Dioxippus
7/21/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
7/23/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Dioxippus
7/23/10
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/6/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Hossam Aboulfotouh
10/8/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/11/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Hossam Aboulfotouh
10/12/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Milo Gardner
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Hossam Aboulfotouh
10/13/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Hossam Aboulfotouh
10/19/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Hossam Aboulfotouh
10/27/07
Read Re: RMP # 48
Matt Hugh

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.