The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: Random numbers
Replies: 64   Last Post: Dec 24, 2007 1:04 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
William Elliot

Posts: 4,698
Registered: 3/18/05
Re: Random numbers
Posted: Dec 22, 2007 6:05 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

On Fri, 21 Dec 2007, quasi wrote:
> <marsh@hevanet.remove.com> wrote:
> >On Fri, 21 Dec 2007, John wrote:
> >

> >> Given a function that returns a random number between 1-5, write one
> >> that returns a random number between 1-7 for the case when it should
> >> be integer and for the case it can be real.
> >>

> >Between 1 and 5 for real numbers means in (1,5).
> >Given a random r in (1,5), 6(r - 1)/4 + 1 is random in (1,7).
> >
> >A random integer between 1 and 5 is 2, 3 or 4.
> >A random integer between 1 and 7 is 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6.

>
> >Let r be a random number in { 2,3,4 }.
> >Let s = 0, if r = 2
> > 1, if r = 3
> >goto let s if r = 4
> >
> >s is a random binary number.
> >
> >Let t = 1 if r = 2, s = 0
> > 2 if r = 2, s = 1
> > 3 if r = 3, s = 0
> > 4 if r = 4, s = 1
> > 5 if r = 5, s = 0
> > 6 if r = 6, s = 1

>
> Very strange. How can r be 4,5,6? The variable r was generated as a
> random integer from the set {2,3,4} with rejection and retry if r = 4,
> so its value must be either 2 or 3.


Oh shucks, the last problem of the night after
I should have gone to sleep.

Let t = 1 if r = 2, s = 0
2 if r = 2, s = 1
3 if r = 3, s = 0
4 if r = 3, s = 1
5 if r = 4, s = 0
6 if r = 4, s = 1

> >t is a random number in { 1,2,3,4,5.6 }.
>
> ??? How did you generate t? There's no mention of t before the above
> line.


It's the random variable
t = 2(r - 2) + s + 1

> >Let d = t if t /= 1
> >goto let d if t = 1

>
> The above 2 lines yield an infinite loop if t = 1.
>

> >d is a random number in { 2,3,4,5,6 }.
>
> Even if your algorithm can be corrected so as to make sense, you're
> making it more complicated than it needs to be.
>

Let t(rnd) be a random variable in { 1,2,3,4,5,6 }
giving a random value each time it's invoked.

:again; tt = t(rnd)
if tt = 1, then goto again
print tt
end

Something similar was done for your algorithm.


Date Subject Author
12/21/07
Read Random numbers
Champ
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Marshall
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Phil Carmody
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Marshall
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
briggs@encompasserve.org
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
William Elliot
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
William Elliot
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Pubkeybreaker
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
b92057@yahoo.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Gib Bogle
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/21/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Marshall
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
adder
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
simple.popeye@gmail.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
Herman Rubin
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
adder
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
b92057@yahoo.com
12/22/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
b92057@yahoo.com
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/23/07
Read Re: Random numbers
b92057@yahoo.com
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
adder
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
quasi
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
adder
12/24/07
Read Re: Random numbers
b92057@yahoo.com

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.