Search All of the Math Forum:
Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by
NCTM or The Math Forum.


Sharon
Posts:
427
From:
NYC
Registered:
6/26/05


Re: a little light humor
Posted:
Jun 30, 2008 3:20 PM



Yes  why not include a diagram? Because SED wants the student to interpret the information.
<sigh>
why not include a diagram lets say
Original Message From: Lidia Gonzalez <euclid6675@aol.com> To: nysmathab@mathforum.org Sent: Mon, 30 Jun 2008 1:46 pm Subject: Re: a little light humor
It?s a matter of what cultural references students from various backgrounds have. If you favor the backgrounds of some over others by embedding the math in contexts that certain students are unfamiliar with then I would agree with Sharon and others who indicate that the exam question(s) is(are) not fair to some. While I do not disagree that part of knowing mathematics is being able to apply it to real life contexts we need to be careful what contexts are used (why not include a diagram lets say) so that some students are not unfairly penalized because even though they know the math, they do not share the same cultural references as those valued by the test makers. We can as teachers talk about and introduce various context and types of problems but these high stakes exams should be written more carefully with respect to contexts. There are a number of individuals that write extensively about this. W. F. Tate (1994, I believe) has a great and compelling article about this.
Lidia G
On 6/29/08 6:22 PM, "msedfun@aol.com" <msedfun@aol.com> wrote:
On Long Island, many homes have rectangular walkways, where the rectangle is outlined in bricks, and the area within the rectangle is cement. So if I lived in Long Island, and all the walkways I saw had bricks around the perimeter, might I not assume that although the problem said 54 SQUARE feet of brick, that I might have to find perimeter? I'm not saying that this is the correct way to interpret a problem, but if SED is giving REAL LIFE APPLICATION  then these kids didn't get a fair shake.
Sharon
And then the thought process is  how could it be a RECTANGULAR walkway if it
is around a garden? Aha! Rectangular means it has the shape of a rectangle.
Much younger students can tell you that.
Original Message
From: numb3rs314 <mstefano@adelphia.net>
To: nysmathab@mathforum.org
Sent: Sat, 28 Jun 2008 7:59 am
Subject: Re: a little light humor
And then the thought process is  how could it be a RECTANGULAR walkway if it
is around a garden? Aha! Rectangular means it has the shape of a rectangle.
Much younger students can tell you that.
For those who think the test should be strictly about math and not reading 
part of math is learning problem solving capabilities. Students are not going
to use a lot of this in life (as they always tell me) but they do need to learn
how to think. Solving math problems is partially a reading test. Students must
read and translate English into algebra. I tell them it's another language they
are learning.
If they can't read and translate the problems by the time they get to this
class, the solution is not dumbing down the test. Go back to the root cause and
fix it!
*******************************************************************
* To unsubscribe from this mailing list, email the message
* "unsubscribe nysmathab" to majordomo@mathforum.org
*
* Read prior posts and download attachments from the web archives at
* http://mathforum.org/kb/forum.jspa?forumID=338
*******************************************************************
Get the Moviefone Toolbar <http://toolbar.aol.com/moviefone/download.html?ncid=aolcmp00050000000011> . Showtimes, theaters, movie news, more!
*******************************************************************
"It will be a fine day when our schools get all the money they
need and the air force has to hold a bake sale to buy a bomber."



