Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » math-history-list

Topic: Prime numbers and pi
Replies: 33   Last Post: Dec 10, 2012 3:43 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Milo Gardner

Posts: 1,105
Registered: 12/3/04
Re: Prime numbers and pi
Posted: Apr 26, 2009 10:01 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Franz,

You keep changing the subject to ones that have no solution that was known to Ahmes. Ahmes' addition, subtraction, multiplication and division methods had changed the arithmetic operations and notations used in the Old Kingdom.

You keep applying the binary Old Kingdom method, used only for Ahmes proofs --- and not initial calculations. Ahmes' arithmetic methods used in the Middle Kingdom - as the RMP clearly reports -- can only be seen after stripping Egyptian fraction notation, as summarized by:

http://ahmespapyrus.blogspot.com/2009/01/ahmes-papyrus-new-and-old.html

from the text.

Your work offers no clue on how to read Ahmes' 2/n table and conversions of rational numbers to optimized unit fraction series. You muddle through like an Englishman (ala Peet) -- by suggesting light -- where there is only darkness!

You speak of the conversion of 63/64, which was easily written as (32 + 16 + 8 + 4 + 2 + 1)/64, as Ahmes used when stating binary quotients, as the dominate notation of the Old Kingdom. In the Middle Kingdom, as Tanja Pemmerening reported in 2002, the 1/64 hekat unit was 'healed', as she fairly reported a dja as 1/64 of a hekat in the Ebers Papyrus, and finalized in her 2005/2006 PhD thesis.

As you know, the Old Kingdom Horus-Eye series only summed to 63/64, throwing away a 1/64 unit - or terrible round-off error.

The Akhmim Wooden Tablet, Kahun P. and all other Middle Kingdom texts solved the problem, in terms of hekat division, by writing

(64/64)/n = Q/64 + (5R/n)*1/320

with Q = quotient, R = remainder and 1/320 = ro, scaled by (5/5).

Of course, Ahmes also divided 10 hekat by writing as 3200 ro in the context:

3200/n = Q + R

as the RMP 66 divided 3200 by 365 with Q = 8 and R = 280/365, scaled to (6/6) (as Robin-Shute and other 20 century scholars like Peet, Chace, Gillings, et al, did not fairly report.

That is, please stop baiting Ahmes' text and switching to an unknown text that is unreadable, and suggesting that Ahmes' text was unreadable. Ahmes' text is readable in almost every respect. There are of course minor issues that are unreadable in the RMP, issues that we can discuss at another time.

Best Regards,

Milo


Date Subject Author
4/12/09
Read Prime numbers and pi
James A. Landau
4/13/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/13/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/13/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
James A. Landau
4/14/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/14/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
6/26/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
hashim shah
4/14/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
James A. Landau
4/15/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/16/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/16/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/16/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/16/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/16/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/18/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/18/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/23/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/23/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
4/25/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/25/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
4/26/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/26/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
4/27/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/27/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/27/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
4/28/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/28/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
4/29/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Franz Gnaedinger
4/15/09
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
John Bibby, QED of York, York, England
6/27/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
6/27/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
12/5/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
kevin
12/6/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner
12/10/12
Read Re: Prime numbers and pi
Milo Gardner

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.