The Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » math-history-list

Topic: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Replies: 62   Last Post: May 18, 2009 2:26 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ] Topics: [ Previous | Next ]
Milo Gardner

Posts: 1,105
Registered: 12/3/04
Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Posted: May 7, 2009 11:45 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Dear Forum members,

Condensing my overly long discussion, let me begin again by mentioning that Chace, 1927, did not report the following transliterated data. The data was provided by Franz when discussing RMP 66.

C'est la quantitée journalière à faire selon qui advient
1 -- 365
2 -- 730
4 -- 1460
"3 -- 243 '3
'10 -- 36 '2
'2190 -- '6
Total 8 "3 '10 '2190

Chace added [ 8 2920 ] a line following line 4 -- 2920

That is, to fairly parse the meaning of Ahmes' transliterated information, Chace's footnotes need not be read in excessive detail, such as - skip the RMP 23 discussion.

It is easy to fully translate Ahmes (if that was his name) and RMP 66's problem statement, initial calculation, and proof by considering:

1. statement of the problem: convert 10 hekat to ro and
divide by 365 days, to obtain the daily usage:

3200/365

a. intermediate answer: 8 + 280/365

b. final answer : 8 + 2/3 + 1/10 + 1/2190

2. Proof:

a. by taking the first column

1 -- 365
2 -- 730
4 -- 1460
[8 -- 2920]

shows that 8 x 365 = 2920, the quotient 8's proof,

b. the remainder (3200 - 2920) = 280/365

was proven by:

(1) 365 times 2/3 = 243 1/3

(2) 365 times 1/10 = 36 1/2

(3) adding 243 1/3 + 36 1/2 = 279 5/6

(4) The missing 1/6 was found by

(5) 2190 times 1/365 = 6, or 1/6 times 365 = 2190

or,

(6). (243 1/3 + 36 1/2 + 1/6) = 280/365

Thus, Ahmes proved that

8 + 2/3 + 1/10 + 1/2190

was initially calculated by the quotient and remainder:

8 + 280/365

Q.E.D.


Date Subject Author
4/29/09
Read RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
4/29/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
4/29/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
4/30/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/1/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/1/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/1/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/2/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/2/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/2/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/2/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/3/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/3/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/3/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/4/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/4/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/4/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/4/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/5/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/5/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/5/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/6/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/6/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/6/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/6/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/7/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/7/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/7/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/7/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/7/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/8/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/8/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/8/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/9/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/9/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/9/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/10/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/10/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/10/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/11/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/12/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/12/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/12/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/12/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/12/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/13/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/13/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/13/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/14/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/14/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/14/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/15/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/16/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/14/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/1/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/15/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Milo Gardner
5/17/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger
5/18/09
Read Re: RMP 66, its initial calculation and diplation proof
Franz Gnaedinger

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.