Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math.independent

Topic: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Replies: 135   Last Post: Jan 6, 2013 5:00 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Mariano

Posts: 1,900
Registered: 8/22/05
Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Posted: May 10, 2009 3:21 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

On May 10, 3:46 pm, Martin Musatov <marty.musa...@gmail.com> wrote:
> "Vagueness is the last refuge for ignorance. Complexity is the last
> refuge for evil."
>
>
>
> Mariano Suárez-Alvarez wrote:

> > On 9 mayo, 05:18, Martin Musatov <marty.musa...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > > An informal and highly experimental, unorthadox proof P=NP has been
> > > published on CERN preprints.

>
> > >http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/1164206/files/s1-ln5758210-9223534-19396...
>
> > > It is mine, and no it is not published anywhere else. My purpose in
> > > posting it here is for feedback and suggestions on how to strengthen
> > > it.

>
> > > I would specifically, as was my intention with this experiment, like
> > > feedback from anyone interested in the methodology I used and
> > > suggestion as to how I might go about pursuing a more broadly accepted
> > > peer-reviewed published proof building on this basic result.

>
> > A two-page, literally unreadable text with nothing in it (at least
> > that did not get mangled) even remotely similar to anything related to
> > computational complexity theory is not something you can get feedback
> > on.
> > It is actually even impossible to see *what* it is you want feedback
> > on.


> *What specifically is "unintelligible"?

It does not even qualify as a text, let alone as
a coherent exposition of an heuristic which may or
may not resolve a mathematical problem.

I simply cannot believe you are serious, for even
a minimally trained Markov chain will do a better job
both at coming up with English prose and at following
minimal usenet conventions in composing posts: even
BURT makes more sense and is more articulate than
you are, and you are less intruiguing than him too.
I trust you will not be particularly disrupted in your
pursuits if I start ignoring you from now on, so I will.

Cheers,

-- m



Date Subject Author
5/9/09
Read P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Denis Feldmann
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
amy666
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/12/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/12/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
A N Niel
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
A N Niel
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Doug Schwarz
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
David C. Ullrich
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Victor Porton
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Doug Schwarz
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Han de Bruijn
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Chip Eastham
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/23/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/23/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/28/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/28/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
9/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
9/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
PianoMan
11/29/12
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
1/6/13
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.