Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Replies: 135   Last Post: Jan 6, 2013 5:00 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Guest

Watch Watch this User
Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Posted: May 11, 2009 1:51 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Answer me:> An informal and highly experimental, unorthadox proof
> P=NP has been
> published on CERN preprints.
>
> http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/1164206/files/s1-ln575821
> 0-9223534-1939656818Hwf-1468147288IdV-1521282711575821
> 0PDF_HI0001.pdf
>
> It is mine, and no it is not published anywhere else.
> My purpose in
> posting it here is for feedback and suggestions on
> how to strengthen
> it.
>
> I would specifically, as was my intention with this
> experiment, like
> feedback from anyone interested in the methodology I
> used and
> suggestion as to how I might go about pursuing a more
> broadly accepted
> peer-reviewed published proof building on this basic
> result.
>
> Thank you,
>
> Martin Musatov
> m[dot]mm[at]vzw[dot]blackberry[dot]net.


Fair warning: Do not be negative or call this post bogus without providing a mathematically sound reason and contradiction to the published proof: if you do this your post will be ignored. I only answer to posts which address me in a humble positive constructive manner with respect to this discussion. There will be no name calling or labelling persons with negative terms like "crank". The mathematician that does this speaks poorly of his own opinion and the reader should be advised that in this context it is highly innapropriate and perhaps downright destructive towards any resolution.


Date Subject Author
5/9/09
Read P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Denis Feldmann
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
amy666
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/12/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/12/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
A N Niel
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
VMCM1905
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
A N Niel
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/17/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/20/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Doug Schwarz
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
David C. Ullrich
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/9/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Victor Porton
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Mariano
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Joshua Cranmer
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Doug Schwarz
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Han de Bruijn
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Jesse F. Hughes
5/13/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/11/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Chip Eastham
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/15/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/16/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/23/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/23/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/28/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
5/28/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
mensanator
9/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
Guest
9/10/09
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
PianoMan
11/29/12
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN
1/6/13
Read Re: P=NP Proof Published at CERN

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.