David R Tribble <email@example.com> wrote in news:b937e776-91cc-45ea-a1ec- firstname.lastname@example.org:
> I worry that a pedant-only newsgroup > would be simply boring by comparison.
I don't think anyone is proposing a "pedant-only" group. No one has suggested a charter that allows only strictly on-topic posts. All suggestions that I'm aware of are of the form "Everything but A, B and C."