Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Education » math-teach

Topic: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Replies: 141   Last Post: Feb 27, 2010 8:36 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Jonathan Groves

Posts: 2,068
From: Kaplan University, Argosy University, Florida Institute of Technology
Registered: 8/18/05
Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Posted: Feb 16, 2010 12:17 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Dear Fellow Mathematicians and Educators,


I had seen recently several articles on "Devlin's Angle" arguing that
multiplication is not repeated addition and should not be taught that way
(at least not as the definition of multiplication). And he makes similiar
comments about exponentiation and repeated multiplication.

Here are the links to his columns addressing this topic:

June 2008: http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_06_08.html

July-August 2008: http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_0708_08.html

September 2008: http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_09_08.html

January 2010: http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_01_10.html

I agree that multiplication is not repeated addition and that exponentiation
is not repeated multiplication--not for real numbers anyway. These are
properties of whole number multiplication and whole number exponentiation,
but, as Devlin says, these properties are not definitions.

He essentially argues that these properties should not be taught as definitions
because then the students will be confused later because they will have to undo
all they've learned about multiplication and exponents of whole numbers
(strictly speaking, we have to disregard an exponent of 0) to
learn multiplication and exponentiation of integers, rational, and real
numbers. In fact, he mentions that he has corresponded with multiple readers
who think multiplication is repeated addition and that exponentiation is
repeated multiplication. So I think his point is valid.

He is correct in that the field properties of the real and complex numbers do
not tell us what the operations are but simply how they behave. Definitions
of the real and complex number operations exist, but the formal, precise
definitions are far too abstract for elementary school and certainly are for
most high schoolers and even adults.

However, teaching students these operations without giving definitions of some
sort doesn't make sense because students want to know what these operations are
and not just how they behave. And it would be difficult for them to
understand these operations conceptually if they don't see any definitions.
I didn't see any ideas in these articles about how we should teach these
operations to students, especially operations with whole numbers.
The usual way is to teach these operations for whole numbers and then extend
those ideas to operations on the integers, rational numbers, and real and
complex numbers. Does anyone have any ideas about this?

I'm sure Keith Devlin is not saying that it's a bad idea for students to
learn that multiplication of whole numbers is repeated addition and that
whole number exponentation (ignoring 0 as an exponent) is repeated
multiplication but is saying that it's a bad idea to teach these properties as
definitions. Does anyone have any ideas on how we can teach these properties
to students and help them to understand that these are not definitions?


Jonathan Groves


Date Subject Author
2/16/10
Read Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/16/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/16/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Louis Talman
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Kirby Urner
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/17/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Louis Talman
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Louis Talman
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Haim
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/19/10
Read Re: Algebra Project
Bishop, Wayne
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/18/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Dave L. Renfro
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Haim
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Haim
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/19/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bill Marsh
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Catherine Sophian
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/20/10
Read Numbers adn Counting
Joe Niederberger
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/20/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Paul A. Tanner III
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/21/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Jonathan Groves
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/22/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Robert Hansen
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/23/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Paul A. Tanner III
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Paul A. Tanner III
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/24/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/26/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joshua Fisher
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger
2/26/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Bishop, Wayne
2/27/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Louis Talman
2/27/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Michael Paul Goldenberg
2/25/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Pam
2/26/10
Read Re: Multiplication Is Not Repeated Addition
Joe Niederberger

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.