Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math.independent

Topic: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right

Replies: 48   Last Post: Jul 7, 2010 9:48 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
eric gisse

Posts: 224
Registered: 10/26/08
Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Posted: Jul 3, 2010 9:18 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

kado@nventure.com wrote:
[...]

> I posted that Einstein derived this GR equation from the 43
> arcsec/centrury of Le Verrier's findings.


He did not.

You are guessing.

[...]

> I hope you know that this equation does not work with the same
> degree of precession when applied to the other planets of the
> Solar System.


It does.

You are, again, guessing.

>
> Furthermore, the values of what T. Roberts claims as errorbars
> are astronomical when applied to many binary extra-Solar System
> bodies.


Error bars from one measurement do not apply to other, independent,
measurements.

You are guessing about a subject you have not adequately studied, and it
shows. Please stop.

>
> So do not expect any more responses to your flummox posts.
>
> To argue with a fool only demonstrates that there are two.
>
> D.Y.K.




Date Subject Author
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Koobee Wublee
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Tom Roberts
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
PD
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
oriel36
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Nick
6/26/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Koobee Wublee
6/29/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Koobee Wublee
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
kado@nventure.com
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Jerry
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Androcles
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
kado@nventure.com
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Jerry
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
PD
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Koobee Wublee
7/3/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
kado@nventure.com
7/3/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/3/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
kado@nventure.com
7/3/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/3/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse
7/4/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/4/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/4/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/4/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Androcles
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse
7/7/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/7/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Androcles
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Androcles
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
Simp
7/5/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse
6/27/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
afe
6/27/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
J. Clarke
6/27/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse
6/27/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
afe
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not
quite right
OwlHoot
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
Androcles
7/2/10
Read Re: GR prediction for precession of perihelion of Mercury is not quite right
eric gisse

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2013. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.