Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Is it possible that 3+4=8?
Replies: 21   Last Post: Jan 29, 2011 9:06 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Tim Little Posts: 1,793 Registered: 2/7/09
Re: Is it possible that 3+4=8?
Posted: Jan 23, 2011 7:29 PM

On 2011-01-23, Craig Feinstein <cafeinst@msn.com> wrote:
> Let's pretend that we live in a world where there are invisible pixies
> running around messing everything up. Let's say you have 3 balls in
> your left hand and 4 balls in your right hand. Whenever you combine
> the balls together, one of these invisible pixies secretly throws in
> another ball, so that whenever you count the balls, you come up with 8
> balls. So in this pretend world, it is a known fact that 3+4=8.

Let's write this as 3' + 4' = 8', where the primed numerals represent
numbers in pixie-world which don't behave the same way as our numbers.
It only takes a moments thought to see that a' = a+1 makes them
equivalent: e.g. 3' + 4' = 4 + 5 = 9 = 8'.

So it would be indistinguishable from a world where people just used
different names for numbers. The arithmetic structure of natural
numbers would be identical.

> My point is that mathematics is considered a deductive science, in
> which everything is absolutely certain. But how can mathematics
> prove that the above scenario cannot be true?

Mathematics is not a science at all, as has been pointed out many
times in a recent thread. Your question is founded on a false
premise.

--
Tim

Date Subject Author
1/23/11 Craig Feinstein
1/23/11 master1729
1/23/11 LudovicoVan
1/24/11 LudovicoVan
1/24/11 LudovicoVan
1/24/11 Virgil
1/23/11 Ilmari Karonen
1/23/11 Ilmari Karonen
1/23/11 Virgil
1/23/11 Tim Little
1/23/11 Joshua Cranmer
1/24/11 hagman
1/24/11 Joshua Cranmer
1/23/11 Brian Chandler
1/24/11 donstockbauer@hotmail.com
1/24/11 cwldoc
1/24/11 Craig Feinstein
1/24/11 Joshua Cranmer
1/24/11 Craig Feinstein
1/25/11 Hauke Reddmann
1/29/11 Bill Taylor