Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math.independent

Topic: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Replies: 74   Last Post: Sep 17, 2011 6:01 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Sam Wormley

Posts: 468
Registered: 12/18/09
Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Posted: Jul 22, 2011 11:33 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
By Mario Livio
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=why-math-works

"Part of the puzzle is the question of whether mathematics is an
invention (a creation of the human mind) or a discovery (something that
exists independently of us). The author suggests it is both.

"Most of us take it for granted that math works?that scientists can
devise formulas to describe subatomic events or that engineers can
calculate paths for space­craft. We accept the view, initially espoused
by Galileo, that mathematics is the language of science and expect that
its grammar explains experimental results and even predicts novel
phenomena. The power of mathematics, though, is nothing short of
astonishing. Consider, for example, Scottish physicist James Clerk
Maxwell?s famed equations: not only do these four expressions summarize
all that was known of electromagnetism in the 1860s, they also
anticipated the existence of radio waves two decades before German
physicist Heinrich Hertz detected them".

See: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=why-math-works



Date Subject Author
7/22/11
Read Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Sam Wormley
7/22/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Sam2718
7/22/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jim
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
patmpowers@gmail.com
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tim Little
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
David Bernier
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tim Little
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Mike Duffy
8/1/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
David Bernier
8/6/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
8/8/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tim Little
8/8/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
David Bernier
8/8/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
8/8/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tim Little
8/9/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
8/10/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jmfbahciv
8/10/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Sam Wormley
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
bjacoby@iwaynet.net
7/23/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jim
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Brian Tenneson
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Brian Tenneson
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
8/4/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
8/4/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tim Little
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jim
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jmfbahciv
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
bjacoby@iwaynet.net
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
bjacoby@iwaynet.net
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
bjacoby@iwaynet.net
7/28/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
at1with0
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
bjacoby@iwaynet.net
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/29/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
7/29/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
8/2/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
8/2/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
8/2/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
hanson
8/2/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
adrian dogsbody
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
mahipal7638@gmail.com
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Androcles
7/26/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Tommy Jensen
9/3/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Rock Brentwood
9/3/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
hanson
7/24/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
byron
7/25/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
byron
7/27/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Frederick Williams
8/5/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
jim
9/4/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Rock Brentwood
9/4/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Wally W.
9/17/11
Read Re: Why Math Works: Is math invented or discovered?
Graham Cooper

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2013. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.