Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » calc_reform

Topic: Re: MindLESS vs MindFUL manipulation
Replies: 44   Last Post: May 27, 1999 8:15 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Kazimierz Wiesak

Posts: 385
Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Posted: Jan 19, 1999 11:12 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply


Thought experiment:
If a typical subscriber to calc-reform completely forgot long division
algorithm, how long would it take him/her to learn it very well?

Since the answer is 'not long', we are talking not so much about teaching
long division algorithm itself (or any other algorithm or "piece" of
mathematics) but more about teaching what can be called "general
mathematical development". And I can see that practicing that algorithm
contributes to arithmetical development of students through, for example,
"how many 14's is there in 88?"

But I wouldn't go as far as to say that we have to teach long division.
Although basic efficiency in mental arithmetic is needed, it can be
achieved in many ways (for example by playing games), not necessarily
through practicing long division. More, some weak students may resent being
forced to struggle so hard with something what they can do so easily on
calculator and the educational effect would be lost.

The long division algorithm is only one example here. In general,
algorithms can be performed by computers and they should be taught to
people only to the extent that they help develop conceptual understanding,
help develop "sense for something" (like "number sense"). And we should not
forget that even if such algorithms do help, they may still be not the
best help available. And I would guess that one of the jobs of reformers
is to look for better ways.


Kazimierz Wiesak






------------------------------------------------------------

-HOW TO UNSUBSCRIBE

To UNSUBSCRIBE from the calc-reform mailing list,
send mail to:

majordomo@ams.org

with the following in the message body:

unsubscribe calc-reform your_email_address


-Information on the subject line is disregarded.




Date Subject Author
12/22/98
Read Re: MindLESS vs MindFUL manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/15/99
Read Algebraic Manipulation
tony asdourian
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Jerry Uhl
1/15/99
Read Algebraic Manipulation
Joshua Zucker
1/17/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Doug Kuhlmann
1/17/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
1/17/99
Read Re: Teaching of Complex Numbers in HS
Susan Schwartz Wildstrom
1/18/99
Read Re: Teaching of Complex Numbers in HS
SANTU DESILVA
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Jerry Uhl
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Geoff Hagopian
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Jerry Uhl
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Jerry Uhl
1/15/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
me@talmanl1.mscd.edu
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Victor Steinbok
1/17/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
SANTU DESILVA
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Tony Asdourian
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
scottp@TEN-NASH.TEN.K12.TN.US
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
John Pais
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
me@talmanl1.mscd.edu
1/16/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
1/17/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
SANTU DESILVA
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
me@talmanl1.mscd.edu
1/18/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Susan Pustejovsky
1/19/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Kazimierz Wiesak
1/19/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/22/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/22/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/22/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/22/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/22/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/23/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
LnMcmullin@aol.com
1/23/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
5/21/99
Read Math as a vehicle for intellectual development
John Evans
5/22/99
Read Re: Math as a vehicle for intellectual development
Arnold Jansen
1/23/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
CalcPage@aol.com
1/23/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits
5/26/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
John A Benson
5/27/99
Read Re: Algebraic Manipulation
Michael Livshits

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.