Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Topic: Enrichment
Replies: 38   Last Post: Aug 24, 2012 1:33 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Robert Hansen Posts: 11,324 From: Florida Registered: 6/22/09
Re: Enrichment
Posted: Aug 15, 2012 10:31 AM

I have this student, in piano class, and all along I have acted as if playing the piano is straightforward and simple, and to me, it is. Only an idiot would fail to play the piano.

Well, the worse has happened. At my insistence he has completed many classes, like Bach and Mozart, but this kid, I tell you, he can barely make noise.

I am thinking of exploring Chopin and Liszt with him to raise his self esteem.

I have accepted that we will be lucky if we get through one bar of each.

Peter, the issue (and it is not the student's fault) is in the first sentence.

Bob Hansen

On Aug 15, 2012, at 9:51 AM, Peter Duveen <pduveen@yahoo.com> wrote:

> I have a student who doesn't do well on tests. He has completed geometry, and will be studying intermediate algebra. I have decided to explore calculus with him.
>
> I hope that, by learning a little of something that his other fellow students know little or nothing about, his self-esteem and interest in the subject can be kindled.
>
> My introduction consists of attempting to define and determine the slope, or inclination if you will, of a curve at a particular point. We use y = x^2. We take two points on the curve and determine the slope of the line that joins them. Then we move one point close to the other.
>
> We say that the slope of the curve at a particular point is the unique quantity approached as one point moves closer to the other, taken as static.
>
> This gentleman may never even take a calculus course. But I feel the slope of a curve at a particular point is not difficult for him to grasp, in the context of math he has already taken. He may also be able to use his insights gained from this introduction to graph equations.
>
> At any rate, this raises the subject of enrichment vs teaching to the test. Is it possible that enrichment can raise the level of cognition, and spark greater interest in the subject, thus actually enhancing performance on tests? One of course must have a varied tool kit to approach the needs of different students.

Date Subject Author
8/15/12 Peter Duveen
8/15/12 Robert Hansen
8/15/12 Robert Hansen
8/15/12 GS Chandy
8/16/12 Peter Duveen
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/16/12 Haim
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 Peter Duveen
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/17/12 Louis Talman
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/17/12 Wayne Bishop
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 Peter Duveen
8/18/12 Robert Hansen
8/18/12 GS Chandy
8/18/12 Peter Duveen
8/19/12 Robert Hansen
8/19/12 Peter Duveen
8/19/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 kirby urner
8/20/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/21/12 kirby urner
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/21/12 Peter Duveen
8/21/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 Wayne Bishop
8/22/12 Robert Hansen
8/21/12 Peter Duveen
8/22/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 Peter Duveen
8/22/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/22/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/24/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/24/12 Robert Hansen