Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Enrichment
Replies: 38   Last Post: Aug 24, 2012 1:33 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Robert Hansen Posts: 11,345 From: Florida Registered: 6/22/09
Re: Enrichment
Posted: Aug 23, 2012 7:01 PM
 att1.html (4.7 K)

On Aug 20, 2012, at 5:29 PM, Dave L. Renfro <renfr1dl@cmich.edu> wrote:

> Jean Gaston Darboux, "Discussion de la fraction
> (ax^2 + bx + c)/(a'x^2 + b'x + c')

I couldn't leave this alone without taking a shot at the general quadratic quotient.

(ax^2 + bx + c) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

Following the same pattern I did with Mike's equation, I am going to put the top expression into a form containing the bottom expression as a term...

ax^2 + bx + c.

Multiply by d/a...

dx^2 + (db/a)x + dc/a

Add and subtract ex and f...

dx^2 + ex + f + (db/a)x - ex + dc/a - f

= (dx^2 + ex + f) + ((db-ea)/a)x + (dc-fa)/a

Now we can put this back into the quotient...

( (dx^2 + ex + f) + ((db-ea)/a)x + (dc-fa)/a ) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

= 1 + 1/a * ( (db-ea)x + (dc-fa)) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

We can drop the constants (1) and (1/a)...

((db-ea)x + (dc-fa)) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

And we can divide by (db-ea)...

( x + (dc-fa)/(db-ea) ) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

At this point we have a term, (dc-fa)/(bd-ea), that we didn't have with Mike's problem. We are going to use a couple substitutions to cajole this into the form we are seeking (a simple square)...

Let k = (dc-fa)/(db-ea), so we don't have to keep writing this mess ...

(x + k) / (dx^2 + ex + f)

Let u = x + k ...

u / (d(u-k)^2 + e(u-k) + f)

= u / ( du^2 - 2dku + dk^2 + eu - ek + f)

Take the reciprocal (like we did in Mike's problem) ...

( du^2 - 2dku + dk^2 + eu -ek + f ) / u

= du - 2dk + e + (dk^2 - ek + f ) / u

Drop the constant terms...

du + (dk^2 - ek + f) / u

divide by d

u + (k^2 - ek/d + f/d) / u

Let j = k^2 - ek/d + f/d ...

u + j/u

= (u^2 + j) / u

Essentially, we are now one step away from the same solution we had for Mike's equation...

Completing the square (note the plus or minus) ...

(u^2 + j) / u +/- 2sqrt(j)

= (u^2 +/- 2sqrt(j)*u + j) / u

= (u +/- sqrtj)^2 / u

= ((u +/- sqrt(j)) / sqrt(u)) ^ 2

A simple square and thus u = +/- sqrt(j)

Substituting x+k back in for u...

x = +/- sqrt(j) - k

where j = k^2 - ek/d + fd and k = (dc-fa)/(db-ea)

If you apply this to Mike's equation you find that k = 0 and j = 2 and the solution is x = +/- sqrt(2), I forgot the +/- in the solution to Mike's equation.

Bob Hansen

Date Subject Author
8/15/12 Peter Duveen
8/15/12 Robert Hansen
8/15/12 Robert Hansen
8/15/12 GS Chandy
8/16/12 Peter Duveen
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/16/12 Haim
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 Peter Duveen
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/17/12 Louis Talman
8/17/12 Robert Hansen
8/17/12 Wayne Bishop
8/17/12 GS Chandy
8/17/12 Peter Duveen
8/18/12 Robert Hansen
8/18/12 GS Chandy
8/18/12 Peter Duveen
8/19/12 Robert Hansen
8/19/12 Peter Duveen
8/19/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 kirby urner
8/20/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/21/12 kirby urner
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/23/12 Robert Hansen
8/21/12 Peter Duveen
8/21/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 Wayne Bishop
8/22/12 Robert Hansen
8/21/12 Peter Duveen
8/22/12 Robert Hansen
8/22/12 Peter Duveen
8/22/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/22/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/24/12 Dave L. Renfro
8/24/12 Robert Hansen