>> GS Chandy Posted: Oct 13, 2012 10:20 AM > >>>If Dr Boaler is correct in her account, then both >>>Professor Milgram and Professor Bishop have much to >>>answer for. >> >> And what if she is not correct? >
>That's an easy one: Then all three of them have much to >answer for.
Gosh, Lou, I had to ponder this for a while (about 3/10 of a nanosecond), but I don't think your answer works for me, at all. If Boaler is not correct, this must allow for the possibility that Milgram and Bishop criticized her WORK in a manner that is fair and reasonable by generally accepted scholarly standards. Why would they have to "answer" for that?
Rather, if Boaler is not correct, then she is twice damned: once for shoddy scholarly work, and once for defamation.