On Oct 30, 1:47 pm, Arturo Magidin <magi...@member.ams.org> wrote: > On Monday, October 29, 2012 6:49:41 PM UTC-5, JRStern wrote: > > On Mon, 29 Oct 2012 13:30:43 -0700 (PDT), Arturo Magidin > > > <magi...@member.ams.org> wrote: > > > >> Doesn't this sound rather like what some of the "cranks" hereabouts > > > >> are trying to say? > > > >Which "cranks", and what specifically do they say that you find > > > >"rather like" exactly which part of the above? > > > >Yet again: one cannot give you an exact answer if you > > > >insist on presenting nothing but vague statements that have > > > >little or no actual content. I certainly have no desire > > > >to waste my time discussing phantoms and ephemerals, > > > >so perhaps you can stop being vague and wishy-washy, > > > >and give some specifics? If you can't, then stop trying > > > >to think about math. Now. Stop. Yes. You. Stop it. > > > >There is absolutely no point in discussing mathematics > > > >on the basis of vague pronouncements, vague statements, > > > >vague "feelings", and vague impressions; because, whatever > > > >it is you end up doing, it's not mathematics. > > > Thank you for trying, although I have clearly not been able to phrase > > > a question that you feel has a useful answer. > > I find your entire participation now entirely frustrating; now you are actively *refusing* to engage in the discussion in any reasonable way, prefering instead to bow out as soon as specifics are requested from you. > > That makes the entire thing nothing but an empty mental exercise on your part, or a successful attempt at having other people waste their time. For which I cannot find any reason to thank you. I do hope, however, that you will be on your way and stop wasting everyone's time, unless you actually want to start engaging in a reasonable manner. > > -- > Arturo Magidin
but you answered his Question beautifully, 'no University would sink to peer review any critique on Cantor's theory'.
This is synonymous with - 'if Cantor's theory was full of holes, we wouldn't know it!'