Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Simulation of 5 Random Variables with Sum Constraint
Replies: 8   Last Post: Apr 3, 2013 3:05 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 Bruno Luong Posts: 9,822 Registered: 7/26/08
Re: Simulation of 5 Random Variables with Sum Constraint
Posted: Mar 28, 2013 5:34 PM

"Siddhartha " <siddhsam@hotmail.com> wrote in message
>
> Thanks for the info Bruno, but the simplex generation seems to strike me as a little odd, especially as seeing that there is no fixed sum constraint.

>
>
> Let me redefine the problem better.
>
> a1 = [10 20 35];
> a2 = [13 19 35];
> a3 = [12 22 35];
> a4 = [15 20 35];
> a5 = [11 19 35];
>
> %Above are detailed the discrete possibilities for each of the 5 variables.
> %There is a 30% chance of low and high, and a 40% chance of base.
>
> Now, these random variables are basically percentages. So their sum can never exceed 100.
> But from some data we know that they can actually never exceed 98.

Steve already told that with 5 variables you can generate the whole set (cardinal <= 243) then randomly pick the one that verify the constraint.

If you have more variables (e.g., > 10), rejection method may be the way to go.

>
> I think, maybe, one can use randfixedsum for each value from min(a1) + min(a2) + min(a3) + min(a4) + min(a5) until 98, in a for loop, but again - that seems inefficient and slow, and I'm having difficulty applying it to the discrete distribution above.

Again Steve told you the discrete and continuous cases are two different problems, involving different maths. Please just pick you choice.

Bruno

Date Subject Author
3/27/13 Siddhartha
3/27/13 Steven Lord
3/27/13 Siddhartha
3/28/13 Steven Lord
3/28/13 Bruno Luong
3/28/13 Siddhartha
3/28/13 Bruno Luong
4/1/13 Siddhartha
4/3/13 Bruno Luong