Paul
Posts:
720
Registered:
7/12/10


Re: Problem understanding proof of Jordan Curve Theorem
Posted:
Jul 11, 2013 3:53 AM


On Wednesday, July 10, 2013 5:02:59 PM UTC+1, dull...@sprynet.com wrote: ... > > It's clear. > > > > The proof I'm about to give is "perfectly clear" in my book. It > > may strike you as something that he should have written > > out in detail because it's not obvious. I disagree  it > > was immediately obvious to me, and the paper was > > written with a certain audience in mind... > ...
But I never said anything remotely critical of the author or the paper. I made the factually correct statement that the lemma was not clear _to me_. What you've done is to arbitrarily come up with a statement that you disagree with, and then to explain your disagreement.
I could follow in your footsteps by saying that I disagree with the statement that English is the most commonly spoken language in Singapore.
On the maths side, the help given by yourself and Rupert is greatly appreciated and I now fully understand why the remark in lemma 3 that I referred to is correct.
Thank You,
Paul Epstein

