Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » Education » math-teach

Topic: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Replies: 61   Last Post: Dec 11, 2013 11:12 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Joe Niederberger

Posts: 3,163
Registered: 10/12/08
Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Posted: Nov 27, 2013 3:18 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

>Isn't that why we dropped the physical metaphors, because you were having problems with them?

I'm just having tongue-in-cheek fun playing with the notions here to illustrate the problems with mixing physical situations with mathematical. When one says "pick a real number at random from (0,1)" that's a sloppy statement. There is no mathematical process of picking, or throwing, or anything else. But those metaphors make their way into the erudite of mathematical texts. A related example is the axiom of choice - in the formal statement there is no "choosing".

In the dart example, if you were just visiting these notions for the first time, then I'm impressed. You got the distinction between "determinable" (computable) as being relevant, and seemed (to me, at least) to be figuring out that the computables are countable and therefore of measure zero.

If you look at link I posted to the "other" discussion, you'll see that this notion of "events" that are "zero probability" but still "possible" is more or less the current official explanation of what's going on here.
Chaitin himself (who I enjoy reading) says the probably is "infinitesimally small". I hope he smiled to himself when he wrote that.

I think "event", and "possible" (and perhaps even "probability") are all thoroughly contaminated with "process thinking" which has teaches a kind of thinking that mathematical objects travel, undergo change, make choices, "happen", etc.

In my view, its only in the physical world that such things occur, but since we are using mathematical objects
to model such processes, the language often bleeds across the lines. It also seems to me that this occurs in probability more than in any other branch. But even in a more fundamental definition, that of "function", some people just cannot accept the notion of a function as an immutable set relation, but insist that the function houses some mysterious "action". Witness Devlin's insistence that there really is a "process" behind real number multiplication.

So, what does it really man to "pick a real number at random from (0,1)?" If you insist on a real, honest to goodness process to do the picking, you are in the realm of computability (and are only dealing with computable numbers anyway,) or physical quantum effects that can be measured, (and thus finite precision numbers, and Heisenberg uncertainty to complicate matters.) There is no conceivable picking process up to the task if you really want to deal with "real" numbers.

All that probability and measure theory really tell you here is individual points and countable collections have measure zero. Saying things like "hitting a particular real number with a dart is an event of zero probability but still possible" is metaphysical nonsense at worst and completely unnecessary at best.

Cheers,
Joe N


Date Subject Author
11/21/13
Read Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Jerry P. Becker
11/21/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Dave L. Renfro
11/21/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Gary Tupper
11/25/13
Read Fwd: Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Gary Tupper
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Gary Tupper
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Fwd: Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/21/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/24/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/25/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Louis Talman
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Gary Tupper
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/26/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/28/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/27/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/28/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/28/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
GS Chandy
11/28/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/28/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
GS Chandy
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
11/29/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
12/4/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
GS Chandy
12/4/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
12/11/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Joe Niederberger
12/11/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
Robert Hansen
12/11/13
Read Re: Visual Presentation of Real Number System
GS Chandy

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.