Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: 4 colors problem
Replies: 86   Last Post: Mar 13, 2014 4:36 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
stumblin' in

Posts: 58
Registered: 3/3/14
Re: 4 colors problem
Posted: Mar 4, 2014 5:26 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

This is an automated computer-generated color scheme, you could say, proving that 4 colors is enough to color a map of countries of any size, shape, location.

(If you mean a human intervention of changing "d" to "c" by itself, for no reason other than because the human could see that "c" will work after the computer figured out everything (wrongly), that's like saying because a program was supposed to give an answer of "32" but it gave "75", just change "75" to "32" and call the program excellent. It does not work that way.
We have to figure out why the program gives a wrong answer.
Maybe the premise was wrong. In this case, maybe saying 4 colors is enough to color any map was only partially right. Maybe it needs to caution that
a country cannot be more than twice long as the rest of the countries on the map for it to work.)

It started out with a unit pattern

A = [a b c d]
[c d a b]

and expanded out to all four directions, always following the convention for adding to the front, back, above, below to color more countries without breaking the unit pattern, thus guaranteeing that 4 color solution will always follow.
But it does not.
As you can see, if you swap "d" with "c" you will have "d d" which follows that the 4 color solution fails.
So the conclusion for this scenario of one country larger than the rest is:
4 color solution fails.

c d a d c d a d c d a b
a b c b a b c b a b c d
c [d d d d d d d d] d* a b
a b c b a b c b a b c d
c d a d c d a d c d a b becomes -->

c d a d c d a d c d a b
a b c b a b c b a b d* d
c [d d d d d d d d] c* a b
a b c b a b c b a b c d
c d a d c d a d c d a b


Date Subject Author
3/3/14
Read 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/3/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/3/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
g.resta@iit.cnr.it
3/3/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
g.resta@iit.cnr.it
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
g.resta@iit.cnr.it
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Port563
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Port563
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read there should be a noncomputer proof of 4CT, I agree
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
g.resta@iit.cnr.it
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Port563
3/4/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
quasi
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
quasi
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/5/14
Read also, what is the spatial analog
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Virgil
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Virgil
3/5/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Virgil
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Virgil
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
ross.finlayson@gmail.com
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colours problem
Robin Chapman
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Peter Percival
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Peter Percival
3/6/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Peter Percival
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Peter Percival
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/7/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Peter Percival
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
magidin@math.berkeley.edu
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/9/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/11/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/11/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/13/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in
3/13/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
Brian Q. Hutchings
3/13/14
Read Re: 4 colors problem
stumblin' in

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.