Date: Sep 7, 2017 10:38 PM
Author: Dan Christensen
Subject: Re: 0 = 1

On Thursday, September 7, 2017 at 9:40:13 PM UTC-4, conway wrote:
> Dan....
> You are starting to play fair. I AGREE that this idea needs a LOT of work. The fact that you are still here....suggest you know at some level "something" might here. Help me! Also I agree my logic can be "garbled". I am a philosopher. Not a mathematician. Mathematics...(indeed all the sciences) were born in philosophy. This idea makes sense. I think you see that. Until now you have refused to take it serious however because you "believe" that I have not done my homework (I have, just not the kind you like). Give me a serious....honest chance to explain this idea to you.
> N = set

Do you mean N is an arbitrary set?

> A = ANY number in the set

So A is an element of N that is also a number? Might there be non-numbers in N?

> z1 = quantity of value (we can work on a more "formal" definition)
> z2 = quantity of space (we can work on a more "formal" definition)
> A = (z1+z2)

So z1 and z2 are simply any pair of numbers such that A = z1+z2?

If A=2 then could we have z1 = 5 and z2 = -3?

> ANY binary expression of multiplication
> z1 x z2
> z2 x z1


> 3 x 2
> z1 for 3 = 3
> z2 for 3 = 3

Doesn't z1+z2 have to be 3?

> z1 for 2 = 2
> z2 for 2 = 2
> 3(as z1) x 2(as z2)
> 3(as z2) x 2(as z1)...
> z1 for 1 = 1
> z2 for 1 = 1
> z1 for 0 = 0
> z2 for 0 = 1

Makes no sense at all. Examples will not do in this context. We need unambiguous definitions. Maybe something of the form: For all x in R, there exists (unique ?) z1 and z2 in R such that _______________ (Fill in the blank)

But even if you manage to do this, you must show how this relationship somehow determines the real value of x where 0x=1. It's just too bizarre. Every elementary school graduate knows that 0x is always 0 for ANY real number x. There can be no doubt about this. I really can't see where you are going with this. Are you deliberately trying to create confusion and frustration among students?


Download my DC Proof 2.0 software at
Visit my Math Blog at