Date: Mar 19, 2004 5:14 PM
Author: Jonathan Welton
Subject: Re: Hex Win Proof?

> (Bill Taylor) wrote in message news:<>...
> > It is an old theorem that in Hex, once the board has been completely
> > filled in with two colours, there *must* be a winning path for one
> > or other of them.
> >
> > Now, I can prove this easily enough mathematically, but I'm wondering if
> > there is a simple proof, or proof outline, that would be understandable
> > and reasonably convincing to the intelligent layman.
> >
> > Can anyone help out please?


Neither of the proofs (which are basically the same) posted so far is
correct. Both would apparently conclude that a winning path would be
formed on a squared board, whereas this is not the case - a squared
board could end in a draw.

An actual proof must use the hex nature of the board or,
alternatively, that 3 cells meet at each vertex. A proof is given in
Cameron Browne's book Hex Strategy, but whether it would convince an
intelligent layman is not clear.

Maybe a simpler proof could be achieved by induction?

Jonathan Welton