The Math Forum

Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Math Forum » Discussions » Education » math-teach

Topic: Conservatives wrongly keep defecating on the US public school system
Replies: 1   Last Post: Mar 13, 2011 11:42 PM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View  
kirby urner

Posts: 3,484
Registered: 11/29/05
Re: Conservatives wrongly keep defecating on the US public school system
Posted: Mar 13, 2011 12:17 PM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply
att1.html (7.8 K)

On Fri, Mar 11, 2011 at 6:22 AM, Paul A. Tanner III <> wrote:

> I replied in
> - --- On Thu, 3/10/11, Robert Hansen <> wrote:

> > From: Robert Hansen <>
> > Subject: Re: Conservatives wrongly keep defecating on the US public

> school system
> > To:
> > Date: Thursday, March 10, 2011, 11:44 AM
> > Paul, I think the "It's Poverty
> > Stupid" analysis has been sufficiently exposed here...
> >
> >


This all seems pretty circular in that the analysis I've seen is along
the lines of: "if North America is consuming 40% of the world's
resources (a commonly cited figure that would need a real source),
then it has no excuse for having the level of poverty it does, ergo
(facile conclusion): the education system Americans use to
brainwash themselves turns them into idiots and dolts."

At this point you get the usual litany of all the "idiotic" things
Americans do and have done around the world (lots of human
sacrifice to the war gods, egged on by TV shows).

There's chauvinism involved here, i.e. a kind of feel good nationalism.
People who don't identify as "Americans" are eager to point out that
other social systems (e.g. theirs) are perhaps less intellectually squalid
and more equitable. This game has been going on a long time, ever
since we had cheerleaders and pep rallies (an ancient tradition,
going back to the Mayans and before).

Foreigners cultivate a superiority complex vis-a-vis the USA in particular,
as Canada looks rather better managed in a lot of ways (in their minds
anyway -- no out-of-control bully-boy troops, hardly any private military
firms who make a living doing craven and cowardly things (as they see it
-- why Afghans asked those firms to leave (but were ignored of course,
as many well-paying jobs were at stake))).

For example, I was reading this book by a Singaporean diplomat, a pretty
high up guy. He feels sorry for Americans, as they'd been a generous
people (more so than the Brits). But now that they've blundered into
being an empire, they've gradually sunk to the level of morons in their
outward behavior. 'The Sorrows of Empire' (by an American) offers a
similar thesis, with movies like 'Charlie Wilson's War' showcasing the
mentality in question (see Notes).

I don't remember to what extent the Singapore guy blames the standard
USA curriculum though, but I'd bet a lot (were I a betting man) that he
considers Singapore's far superior. Here in Portland, high schoolers
attach the most prestige to IB (over AP), an indication that
anti-Americanism is alive and well here as well (Howard Zinn is
required reading -- fortunately our household has quasi-unlimited
access (lots of IB going on)).

In sum, the skeptics are having an "I told you so" field day regarding
Americans, thanks to its uncoordinated / spastic invasions based
on spurious / concocted data (in Asia too). Sneering ridicule is the
order of the day. A lot of tourists buy "I'm Canadian" shirts and learn
to say "eh" when traveling abroad.

The Iranians feel especially vindicated in having called the USA a
"great satan" all these years, as the connotation in Farsi is of a
foolish beast, a decadent numbskull, a thoroughly pathetic and
despicable being, nothing to do with the Satan some USAers
surreptitiously and superstitiously worship, as some wicked-smart
intellect ala Anton LaVey. That'd be a big step up from the
Iranian point of view, or so sources tell me (lots of Iranians in
Portland by the way).

I think the grad schools still get a lot of respect, but then these
have become supranational in flavor, depending on a global cast
of characters at both the faculty and student level. Like many
corporations, the sovereign flag these entities presume to fly
has to be taken with a grain of salt (healthy skepticism) as under
the hood their allegiances are more global than local. Like
Ben & Jerry's is Anglo-Dutch (whatever that means). Remember
when Burger King used to fly those giant Stars & Stripes, even
though it was owned by a UK-based consortium at the time?
Talk about bread and circuses for the Roman hoi polloi.

One could argue this was the fate of the USA to begin with, to
lay a foundation for global infrastructure (e.g. the Internet). In
that sense, there's still a lot of respect for that engineering prowess,
but it doesn't trickle down to those Wall Street people, who just
come across as uber-greedy and ignorant, for the most part. Most
the engineers are in California and such places (yes, these are
all silly stereotypes, but I'm trying to get across why a faulty
education system is still to blame in many circles, and held
up as an example of how *not* to do things if you wanna really
succeed in this world).



Beyond the Age of Innocence by Kishore Mahbubani
(re Charlie Wilson's War)
high schoolers debate satanism -- note misspellings
("number 1, lose the gun..." -- more Michael Moore groupies eh?)

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.