Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: L'Hospital is NOT Blind
Replies: 3   Last Post: Dec 1, 2004 12:33 AM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 J. J. Sroka Posts: 85 Registered: 12/6/04
L'Hospital is NOT Blind
Posted: Oct 22, 2004 4:36 PM

In a previous post, Karplus and Chapman both referred to "blindly"
applying L'Hospital's Rule.

Let me make a point about using L'Hospital's Rule by using a much more
poignant (thank you, Tommy Smothers) example.

Problem 1. Find lim x -&gt; 0 (sin(x)/x).

Problem 2. Prove that lim x -&gt; 0 (sin(x)/x) = 1.

If Problem 1 were given to a person who hadn't used calculus much
recently, and had forgotten the seminal importance of that limit (**), but
*had remembered* L'Hospital's Rule, that person could quickly and
effectively *find* that limit using L'Hospital's Rule:

lim x -&gt; 0 (sin(x)/x) = lim x -&gt; 0 (cos(x)/1) = 1/1 = 1.

Here, of course we have used d/dx (sin(x)) = cos (x).

So, if all that were asked for is to find (compute) that limit, then
L'Hospital's Rule probably is that person's only hope of getting the
correct answer, and I would say that using it to solve Problem 1 is
effective and correct.

-------

If Problem 2 were given in isolation, with no context given that would
indicate whether L'Hospital's Rule were too advanced or not yet covered in
the course, then I would still say that using L'Hospital's Rule is
effective and correct, although I would expect that some would argue the
contrary.

--------

(**) The limit lim x -&gt; 0 (sin(x)/x) = 1 is used to *derive* the formula
d/dx (sin(x)) = cos (x).

--------

As to the original problem that Karplus and Chapman referred to, since it
is do-able without L'Hospital, one could say that Karplus used an elephant
gun to kill a fly, but that the shooter was NOT blind.

There is a problem very similar to this (page 110, #30) in Stewart's
"Calculus Early Transcendentals" 4th. Ed. This is well in advance of
Stewart's presentation of L'Hospital.

So, I would have to say that Karplus used a high-caliber method (Ka-Boom!).

--- Joe (Sent via 10.2.8 at 12:51pm PDT 10-22-2004).

--
Delete the second "o" to email me.

--
submissions: post to k12.ed.math or e-mail to k12math@k12groups.org
private e-mail to the k12.ed.math moderator: kem-moderator@k12groups.org
newsgroup website: <a href="http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/">http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/</a>
newsgroup charter: <a href="http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/charter.html">http://www.thinkspot.net/k12math/charter.html</a>

Date Subject Author
10/22/04 J. J. Sroka
11/19/04 Steve
11/20/04 Peter
12/1/04 J. J. Sroka