The NCSM has been carefully reading the NMP discussions on the TODOS listserv and on their special NMP discussion group. Jerry Becker's listserv has also included many, many articles and additional information on the Panel.
I have been in conversation with Skip Fennel, President of NCTMl; Miriam Leiva, president of TODOS; Bob Kansky, former MSEB director who has a good history and pulse on Washington DC "mentality"; and Steve Leinwand, past president of NCSM and many others about the make- up of the panel and their work. There has been much very good conversation about the concerns of the make-up of the panel and what we believe should be their work including -- reaching all students -- doing what is right for kids -- and how the panel will react to what we think to be should be their plan both on the internet and in the media.
I am concerned about signing a petition such as that described below. Deborah Ball has worked very hard to get some of the initial founders and supporters of the mathematically correct to sit and talk with her, Hy Bass, other mathematicians and mathematics educators to reach some "Common Ground" on what is good for students. I have seen Skip Fennel "in action" with some of the folks who have very strong opinions. He will challenge their thinking. They will represent our beliefs on this panel. (Ten -- even 5 years ago, we would not have had the president of NCTM even invited to be in the room! )
I think signing a petition to remove one person from this panel is dangerous. If you wish, call for the entire panel's dissolution -- but do not focus on one person.
Since I am unable to attend the second panel meeting, I have asked Janie Zimmer, a long time active member of NCTM and NCSM and a current regional director of NCSM to attend the second panel meeting and request to address the panel. Janie is knowledgeable about the issues and she is very articulate. She has had input from other NCSM regional directors. She and I have talked at length. Please know that the vision and mission of NCSM involving equity for all students in mathematics education will be made known in Janie's comments. I believe that Miriam Leiva has also asked to address the panel.
In the meantime, check out http:// mathpanelwatch.blogspot.com/ for updates on the work of the panel. I also suggest we flood the offices of our congress people and senators with information about our concern of the work of the panel. Heck, contact panel members... you can find their contact information. Let them know your convictions about mathematics education for all -- and how we should be teaching mathematics.
I do recommend we become political -- it is my belief that a petition aimed at removing one person is not the way to go.
Linda Gojak President, NCSM Supporting Leadership in Mathematics Education CMSETT John Carroll University 216 397 4574 (o) www.ncsmonline.org firstname.lastname@example.org
The person who says it cannot be done should not interrupt the person doing it. ...Chinese Proverb
On Jun 23, 2006, at 2:30 PM, Dara Sandow wrote:
> I thought some might be interested in the following ... > >> From: Cathy Kessel <email@example.com> >> Date: Fri, 23 Jun 2006 09:24:41 -0700 >> To: Rume@betterfilecabinet.com >> Subject: [RUME] Petition concerning National Mathematics Advisory >> Panel >> List-Id: "Discussion list for the SIGMAA on RUME. " >> <rume_betterfilecabinet.com.betterfilecabinet.com> >> >> As you may know, the president of the United States has created a >> National Mathematics Advisory Panel. According to the Executive >> Order, the Panel is to "foster greater knowledge of and improved >> performance in mathematics among American students." More information >> about the panel, its charge, and its members is available at: http:// >> www.ed.gov/about/bdscomm/list/mathpanel/index.html >> >> The Vice-chair of the Panel is Camilla Benbow, who is best known for >> the hypothesis that there are intrinsic gender differences in favor >> of males at the highest level of mathematical performance. For >> evidence against this hypothesis and for criticisms of Dr. Benbow's >> work see http://www.awm-math.org/benbow_petition/background.html. >> >> The Association for Women in Mathematics has approved a petition >> urging the removal of Dr. Benbow from the Panel in order to >> avoid actual or perceived bias against women and girls in the Panel's >> recommendations. >> >> To sign the petition, please see http://www.awm-math.org/ >> >> --Cathy (president-elect of AWM) >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Rume mailing list >> Rume@betterfilecabinet.com >> http://betterfilecabinet.com/mailman/listinfo/ >> rume_betterfilecabinet.com >