Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Spencer-Brown's purported proof of Riemann Hypothesis
Replies: 8   Last Post: Aug 7, 2006 12:17 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 john baez Posts: 460 Registered: 12/6/04
Re: Spencer-Brown's purported proof of Riemann Hypothesis
Posted: Aug 6, 2006 6:05 AM

In article <je2dnSC6K7IEWVbZnZ2dnUVZ_qWdnZ2d@comcast.com>,
Tim Peters <tim.one@comcast.net> wrote:

>He claims that these first few pages prove:
>
> |pi(n) - li(n)| < sqrt(li(n)) [3]
> for all n > 1

>Anyway, /if/ [3] holds RH follows, because:
>
>a. sqrt(li(n)) < sqrt(n) for n > 1 (which he notes)
>
>b. so |pi(n) - li(n)| < sqrt(n) for n > 1 would follow from [3]
>
>c. RH is equivalent to the statement (which he alludes to, but doesn't
> give) that there's some constant C for which:
>
> |pi(n) - li(n)| < C sqrt(n) log(n)
>
> holds for all sufficiently large n; or, IOW,
>
> pi(n) = li(n) + O(sqrt(n) log(n))
>
>So [3], if true, is in fact a substantially tighter bound than required to
>prove RH.

At first I thought it might be too tight to be true - but now
I guess such a bound has not yet been ruled out.

In Bombieri's article on the Riemann Hypothesis:

http://www.claymath.org/millennium/Riemann_Hypothesis/Official_Problem_Description.pdf

he writes:

"The validity of the Riemann hypothesis is equivalent to saying
that the deviation of the number of primes from the mean Li(x) is

pi(x) = Li(x) + O(sqrt(x) log x);

the error term cannot be improved by much, since it is known to
oscillate in both directions to order at least Li(sqrt(x)) log log log x
(Littlewood)."

But, unless I'm making a mistake, Li(sqrt(x)) log log log x
is eventually much smaller than Spencer-Brown's claimed bound sqrt(Li(x)).

Of course this has nothing to do with whether his "proof" makes sense.

Date Subject Author
7/28/06 Matthew Watkins
7/28/06 G. A. Edgar
7/28/06 victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
7/29/06 Christopher J. Henrich
7/29/06 Tim Peters
8/6/06 john baez
8/6/06 Tim Peters
8/7/06 victor_meldrew_666@yahoo.co.uk
8/6/06 john baez