The Math Forum

Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Math Forum » Discussions » Inactive » Historia-Matematica

Topic: [HM] Archimedes: On the Sphere and Cylinder, Prop. 2
Replies: 0  

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List  
Robert (Bob) Eldon Taylor

Posts: 101
Registered: 12/3/04
[HM] Archimedes: On the Sphere and Cylinder, Prop. 2
Posted: Oct 21, 2006 9:52 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

Greetings to All,

Archimedes (in On the Sphere and Cylinder Prop. 2 ) asserts:

"Given two unequal magnitudes, it is possible to find two unequal
straight lines such that the greater straight line has to the less a
ratio less than the greater magnitude has to the less."

He begins his proof:

"Let AB, D be two unequal magnitudes, and let AB be the greater. "

And then says:

"By the second proposition in the first book of Euclid let BG be placed
equal to D"

The proposition referred to is surely not the second in the modern
numbering scheme, but perhaps the third:

"To cut off from the greater of two given unequal straight lines a
straight line equal to the less."

But Euclid I.3 is about lines, not general magnitudes, and, it seems to
me, is useless in this case. (But how can such a great mathematician
make such an error? Perhaps the statement is an interpolation.) What is
needed here is not a reference to a theorem, nor even a postulate, but
to a definition of magnitude, namely, that a magnitude is such a thing
that, of two unequal magnitudes of the same kind, the less can be "cut
off" from the greater.

Magnitude was never defined, and one can see why - the difficulty of the
thing is very great.

Another possibility is that I am really confused - not for the first
time this week.

Regards from a sunny, chilly Comer, Georgia,
Robert Eldon Taylor
philologos at mindspring dot com

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© The Math Forum at NCTM 1994-2017. All Rights Reserved.