Drexel dragonThe Math ForumDonate to the Math Forum



Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by Drexel University or The Math Forum.


Math Forum » Discussions » sci.math.* » sci.math

Topic: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Replies: 57   Last Post: Dec 17, 2007 11:30 AM

Advanced Search

Back to Topic List Back to Topic List Jump to Tree View Jump to Tree View   Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
Denis Feldmann

Posts: 533
Registered: 4/23/06
Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Posted: Dec 17, 2007 12:29 AM
  Click to see the message monospaced in plain text Plain Text   Click to reply to this topic Reply

mike3 a écrit :
>>
>>> This is also fine. But that doesn't mean it
>>> produces a finite extent of continuum, unless you take real numbers
>>> *are* the continuum, which we could not establish so far.

>> No. The proof that a set with beth-one real numbers can have finite
>> extent is a fairly elementary proof, that does not involve any
>> concept of "contiuum", just the definition of measure.
>> The proof is not difficult, but you will not find it on Wikipedia.
>> You will need to consult an introductory measure theory text.
>>

>
> What about another free (gratis) source that is NOT Wikipedia?


Why not try making your own proofs?

And why bother with that troll ? (anybody mentioning beth-1 (and
wikipedia, etc.) for a (lack of) proof that singletons of reals have
(Lebesgue) measure 0 ans intervals have measure (b-a)>0 *is* a troll.)


>


Date Subject Author
11/25/07
Read A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
G.E. Ivey
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
lwalke3@lausd.net
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
lwalke3@lausd.net
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
drmwecker@gmail.com
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
drmwecker@gmail.com
11/25/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Ross Finlayson
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
tommy1729
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
William Hughes
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
William Hughes
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
William Hughes
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Randy Poe
11/26/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Randy Poe
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Virgil
11/27/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Han de Bruijn
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Virgil
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Randy Poe
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
lwalke3@lausd.net
11/28/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Jonathan Hoyle
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
vreddyp@gmail.com
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Dik T. Winter
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
G. Frege
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Dik T. Winter
11/30/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Dik T. Winter
12/3/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Han de Bruijn
12/3/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Marshall
12/3/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Dik T. Winter
11/29/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Randy Poe
12/3/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
12/3/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
12/16/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
mike3
12/17/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
Denis Feldmann
12/17/07
Read Re: A flaw with Venkat Reddy's arithmetic.
FredJeffries@gmail.com

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in this topic.

[Privacy Policy] [Terms of Use]

© Drexel University 1994-2014. All Rights Reserved.
The Math Forum is a research and educational enterprise of the Drexel University School of Education.