Search All of the Math Forum:

Views expressed in these public forums are not endorsed by NCTM or The Math Forum.

Notice: We are no longer accepting new posts, but the forums will continue to be readable.

Topic: Having a hard time with proofs
Replies: 8   Last Post: Feb 23, 2008 3:53 PM

 Messages: [ Previous | Next ]
 BST Posts: 19 From: Simon Fraser University Registered: 9/6/07
Having a hard time with proofs
Posted: Feb 6, 2008 1:25 PM

Since making free PDF copies of our real analysis texts on our site ClassicalRealAnalysis.com we get an occasional appeal for help from users of the texts. In this case I think the wise advice from many on this forum would help too. Please jump in with your suggestions.

Here is the letter to us and my response.

*****************************************
R---- writes:

I happened across your book while doing some research on textbooks that could help me learn real analysis.

I've found that a lot of the topics I run into while working in AI and finance requires an understanding of real analysis. I've taken a significant amount of mathematics, statistics, differential equations, MVC, and linear algebra.

However, I'm finding myself getting stuck in ruts while trying to prove a lot of the exercises in the first chapter! Needless to say, it's quite frustrating when you can obviously see that it's true but can't formulate it into a proof. I realize that part of the battle to becoming good at math is being able to formulate the proofs on your own.

I was wondering if there were any hints or tips or books that I could read to help me with my inexperience in creating proofs.

Lastly, I greatly thank you for putting your book up online. I don't think I would have found it otherwise.

Thanks, R-------
*********************

My response:

Hi R------,
Don't be discouraged. I would say 95% of my students over the years would have said the same thing about proofs.

The Elementary Real Analysis text has an appendix where we talk about this. Certainly go there to be sure you know about Indirect Proofs, Direct Proofs, Contraposition and Proofs by Induction.

I would often for an exam announce in advance that a full proof would be required and tell the students explicitly which theorem. Even then many failed. So a first step is
to pick a theorem you like and MEMORIZE the proof and present that proof to as many people as are willing to listen. [I think of it like a jazz solo. If you want to learn how to improvise, first memorize someone's nice solo and perform it as often as you can. Your creativity won't follow until you learn first how to imitate.]

I am posting this on the alt.math.undergrad site and I'm hoping that others will have suggestions on how they managed to make this transition. Its way too many years back for me to remember how I managed, but I suspect it was because we studied Euclid in high school and had to produce hundreds of proofs in that style.
********************************

Date Subject Author
2/6/08 BST
2/6/08 Cindy
2/7/08 Frederick Williams
2/6/08 BST
2/11/08 phubaba
2/11/08 BST
2/12/08 Frederick Williams